秒速赛车6码计划

法律論文范文欄目為您提供《互聯網法院審判現狀與困境破解》范文一篇,希望對您在論文寫作的時候有所幫助
您當前的位置:高質代筆網 > 論文范文 > 法律論文范文 >

互聯網法院審判現狀與困境破解

添加時間:2019/10/12

  摘要:秒速赛车6码计划隨著信息通訊技術對社會各領域影響的深入,互聯網法院作為司法主動適應互聯網發展大趨勢的一項重大創新制度,自設立即引起世人的矚目。然而,檢索分析北京、廣州與杭州互聯網法院設立至今的全部裁判文書,不難發現,在對互聯網法院訴訟便捷、司法高效過多渲染之下,卻忽略了互聯網法院審判發展的瓶頸,甚至淡漠了互聯網法院應承擔的專業化審判的司法責任。破解互聯網法院審判受制于現行民事訴訟法所確立的訴訟制度與程序規則困境的關鍵,在于以“網上案件”超越物理空間地域的本質特征為基礎,走出互聯網法院系集中管轄“網上案件”特殊法院的誤區,使互聯網法院回歸審判專業性案件專門法院的定位。

  關鍵詞:互聯網法院; 涉網案件; 跨地域性; 專門法院;

  SHANGSHIJI90 NIANDAIYILAI,XINXITONGXUNJISHUYUNYONGDEGUANGFANYUBIANJIE,BUJINJIDADIYINGXIANGZHURENMENDESHENGHUO、XUEXIHEGONGZUOFANGSHI,YINGXIANGZHUZHENGFUYUSHIMINSHEHUIDEJIAOHUFANGSHI,ERQIEBUKEBIMIANDIGEIGEGUODESUSONGZHIDUYUSHENPANFANGSHIDAILAIJUDADEYINGXIANGYUCHONGJI。DIANZISUSONGDECHUXIANHEFAZHANSHIXINXITONGXUNJISHUDUISIFASHENPANZHIDUYINGXIANGDEBIRANCHANWUHEJIEGUO,YESHIGUOJIAXINXIHUAZHANLVEZAISIFASHENPANZHONGDEJUTIZHANXIAN。ZI1999NIAN10YUE20RIZUIGAORENMINFAYUANBANBU《RENMINFAYUANWUNIANGAIGEGANGYAO》,JIANGCAIYONGXINXIJISHUJIANLIZAIXIANSHENPANTIZHIZUOWEISIFAGAIGEDEZHONGYAONEIRONGYILAI,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANXIANGJIFABULEYIXILIEGUANYURENMINFAYUANXINXIHUAJIANSHEDESIFAWENJIAN,JIDADITUIDONGLEWOGUORENMINFAYUANXINXIHUAJIANSHEDEJINCHENG。ZHONGGUOFAYUANDEXINXIHUAJIANSHECONGYUANCHENGSHIPINSHENPAN、KEJIFATINGFAZHANDAOZHIHUIFAYUAN。2017NIAN6YUE26RI,ZHONGYANGQUANMIANSHENHUAGAIGELINGDAOXIAOZUDISANSHILIUCIHUIYISHENYITONGGUOLE《GUANYUSHELIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANDEFANGAN》,ZHONGYANGSHENGAIZUHUIYIQIANGDIAO,“SHELIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN,SHISIFAZHUDONGSHIYINGHULIANWANGFAZHANDAQUSHIDEYIXIANGZHONGDAZHIDUCHUANGXIN。YAOANZHAOYIFAYOUXU、JIJIWENTUO、ZUNXUNSIFAGUILV、MANZUQUNZHONGXUQIUDEYAOQIU,TANSUOSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZE,WANSHANSHENLIJIZHI,TISHENGSHENPANXIAONENG,WEIWEIHUWANGLUOANQUAN、HUAJIESHEWANGJIUFEN、CUJINHULIANWANGHEJINGJISHEHUISHENDURONGHEDENGTIGONGSIFABAOZHANG”。[1]SHELIHULIANWANGFAYUANTUPOLECHUANTONGFAYUANDESHEZHIMOSHI,QIHEWANGLUOKONGJIANJIUFENJIEJUEDEDUTEXING。

  SHIYINGHULIANWANGSHIDAISIFADEXIANSHIXUQIU,BEIYUWEI“SIFALINGYULICHENGBEISHIDESHIJIAN”。2017NIAN8YUE18RI,HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANZHENGSHIGUAPAI,ZUOWEIQUANQIUSHOUJIADINGWEIYUYI“HULIANWANGFANGSHISHENLISHEHULIANWANGANJIAN”DEHULIANWANGFAYUAN,WEIGOUJIANWANGLUOSHIDAIDEXINXINGSIFASHENPANFANGSHITIGONGLEXIANHUODESHIJIANYANGBEN。CIHOU,2018NIAN9YUE9RI,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANGUAPAICHENGLI。2018NIAN9YUE28RI,GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANGUAPAICHENGLI。SUIZHUSANJIAHULIANWANGFAYUANDEXIANGJIGUAPAICHENGLI,WOGUODEDIANZISUSONGYEFAZHANDAOLEYIGEXINDEJIEDUAN。JINLIANGNIANLAI,ZHANZAISIFATIZHIGAIGECHAOTOUDEHULIANWANGFAYUANNINGJULESHEHUIGEJIEGUANGFANGUANZHU,RANER,HULIANWANGFAYUANZISHELIZHIJINDESHENPANSHIJIANXIANZHUANGRUHE,QIZAIYIJIEJUECHUANTONGFEIWANGSHANGMINSHIJIUFENWEIJICHUDESUSONGLILUNZHIDAOXIAXINGCHENGDEXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEKUANGJIANEIYUNXING,JIUJINGHUIZAOYUZENYANGDEZHIDUKUNJING,XUYAOSHENSHENFENXI。

  一、互聯網訴訟面臨制度挑戰

  YIHULIANWANGJISHUWEIYITUODEQUANXINSHIDAIBEICHENGZHIWEI“HULIANWANGSHIDAI”、“DASHUJUSHIDAI”、“ZHINENGHUASHIDAI”。JUHULIANWANGZHONGXIN2018NIANDI42CIZHONGGUOHULIANWANGLUOFAZHANZHUANGKUANGTONGJIBAOGAOXIANSHI:JIEZHI 2018 NIAN 6 YUE,WOGUOWANGMINGUIMOWEI8.02 YI,SHANGBANNIANXINZENG2968 WANREN,JIAO 2017 NIANMOZENGJIA 3.8%,HULIANWANGPUJILVDA 57.7%。WOGUOSHOUJIWANGMINGUIMODA 7.88 YI,SHANGBANNIANXINZENG3509 WANREN,JIAO2017 NIANMOZENGJIA 4.7%。WANGMINZHONGSHIYONGSHOUJISHANGWANGRENQUNDEZHANBIYOU 2017 NIANDE 97.5%TISHENGZHI 98.3%,WANGMINSHOUJISHANGWANGBILIJIXUPANSHENG。WOGUOWANGLUOZHIFUYONGHUGUIMODADAO5.69YI,JIAO2017NIANMOZENGJIA3783WANREN,BANNIANZENGCHANGLVWEI7.1%,SHIYONGBILIYOU68.8%TISHENGZHI71.0%。WANGLUOZHIFUYICHENGWEIWOGUOWANGMINSHIYONGBILIJIAOGAODEYINGYONGZHIYI。QIZHONG,SHOUJIZHIFUYONGHUGUIMOZENGCHANGXUNSU,DADAO5.66YI,BANNIANZENGCHANGLVWEI7.4%,ZAISHOUJIWANGMINZHONGDESHIYONGBILIYOU70.0%TISHENGZHI71.9%。WOGUONONGCUNWANGMINGUIMOWEI2.11YI,ZHANZHENGTIWANGMINDE 26.3%,JIAO 2017 NIANMOZENGJIA 204 WANREN,ZENGFUWEI 1.0%;CHENGZHENWANGMINGUIMOWEI 5.91 YI,ZHANBIDA 73.7%,JIAO 2017 NIANMOZENGJIA2764 WANREN,ZENGFUWEI 4.9%。[2]HULIANWANGYONGHUGUIMOYIJIWANGLUOZHIFUBILIDETISHENGBIRANYINFASHEWANGMINSHANGSHIJIUFENDEDALIANGFASHENG。

秒速赛车6码计划   SHINIANQIAN,DEGUOXUEZHEBIANYUYAN,DIANZISUSONGJIANGYIJIBUPINGHENGDECHENGDUBOJIFATINGSUSONGCHENGXU,BAOKUOSUSONGXINGSHI、FALVRENHESUSONGDANGSHIRENDEXINGWEIFANGSHIYIJIFUZADUOYANGDESUQIANCHENGXU、SUZHONGCHENGXUHESUHOUCHENGXU。[3]P308HULIANWANGSHIDAIZHONG,WEIXIN、QQ、DIANZIYOUJIANDENGJISHIDIANZISHOUDUANLIANXIYIJINGKUAYUEKONGJIANDIYUQUDAILECHUANTONGDEMIANDUIMIANJIAOWANGHEJIAOYIFANGSHI,DIANZISHANGWUFANGSHIYOUCHAOYUECHUANTONGJIAOYIFANGSHIDEQUSHI,JIAOYIXUANCHUAN、DINGHUO、BAOJIABIAO、HUOPINXINXI、DIANZIPIAOJU、DIANZIPINGZHENG、FAHUOTONGZHI、SHOUHUOQUEREN、SHANGPINWEIHUXINXI、SUOPEIQINGQIUDENGJIAOYIGUOCHENGDOUYISHUZIFANGSHICHENGXIAN。YIDANSHESONG,ZHEXIEWENBEN、SHUJUYUYINSHIPINZILIAORUGUOZAIYISHUMIANFANGSHIDAYINTIJIAO,FANDAOCHENGWEIZHENGJUFUBEN,BUDANYUZUIJIAZHENGJUGUIZEXIANGBEI,ERQIEFEISHIHAOLI。[4]YINCI,CHENGZAIXINXIDEWULIJIEZHIYIJIJIAOLIUCHANGYUDEBIANHUA,BIRANHUIXIANGYINGDIGAIBIANDANGSHIRENSUSONGXINGWEIYUFAYUANSHENPANXINGWEIDEFANGSHI。CHUANTONGSUSONGZHONG,DANGSHIRENBICIZHIJIANYIJIYUFAGUANZHIJIANYONGYUYANYIJIYOUXINGWULIJIEZHICHENGZAIDEWENZI、TEZHENGDENGJINXINGXINXICHUANDI,BINGQIETONGGUOCHUANTONGFATINGZHEYITEDINGKONGJIANCHANGYUSUOXINGCHENGDEWULISHANGDEZHIJIELIANXIJINXINGJIAOLIU,XIANGYINGDISUZAOLECHUANTONGSUSONGYINGYOUDEJIBENYUANZE、ZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZE,YIJISHUMIANANJUANCUNDANGJISHU。DIANCIBOCHUANDIXINXIFANGSHIDECHUXIAN,JIANGSHITINGZILIAOZHEYIZHENGJUXINGSHIDAIRUSUSONG,DANRENHEXINXIJISHUDOUWUFAYUHULIANWANGPIMEI,HULIANWANGJISHUPUJIHOU,GAIBIANLESUSONGZILIAODECHENGZAIYUCHUANDIFANGSHI,BINGQIEKEYISHIDANGSHIRENBICIYIJIYUFAGUANZAIXUNIKONGJIANZHONGDEDIANZIFATINGJINXINGSUSONGXINGWEIDEJIAOLIU,KEJIAN,HULIANWANGJISHUSHIDEYUNYONGDIANZISHUJUCHULIXITONGCHULIANJIANDEJINGJIXINGHEXUNSUXINGYOUSHITUXIANCHULAI,SHUZIHUADESHIPINHUIYIJISHUYEKEYIZAIDANGSHIRENHEFAYUANLIANGGEJIAODUFANGBIANDILIYONG,ERQIEHUANKEYIXIAOCHUHUOHUANJIEMIANDUIMIANSUSONGGEIDANGSHIRENDAILAIDEKONGJUGAN。[4]YINCI,XUNIKONGJIANZHONGDEDIANZIFATINGMOUZHONGCHENGDUSHANGYEXUERUOLESIFAYISHIZAIBAOZHANGSIFAGONGZHENGFANGMIANDEZUOYONG。

  SUIZHUHULIANWANGJISHUZAISIFASHENPANZHONGDEYUNYONG,SUSONGDEDIANZIHUA、XINXIHUAZAIHENDUOGUOJIADEMINSHISUSONGZHONGYIBUTONGFANGSHI、BUTONGCHENGDUZHANXIANCHULAI,DIANZISIFA、DIANZISUSONG、DIANZIFAXIANCHENGXUHUOYUEDIANZISHENQIANZHENGJUKAISHICHENGXU、DIANZIWENJIANTIJIAO、DIANZIFATING、DIANZIZHENGJU、DIANZISONGDADENGZAIYIXIEGUOJIACHENGWEIERSHUNENGXIANGDEGAINIAN。[5]KEJIAN,HULIANWANGJISHUDEXUNSUFAZHANYUGUANGFANYUNYONGBUJINGAIBIANLEMINZHONGDESHENGHUOFANGSHI,YIJISIFALINGYUZHONGCHUANTONGMINSHANGSHIFALVGUANXIDECHANSHENG、BIANGENGYUXIAOMIEDEFANGSHI,ERQIEYEJIDADIGAIBIANLEMINSHISUSONGZHEYIGONGFALINGYUDEJIAOWANGFANGSHI,TAZAIHENDACHENGDUSHANGBAITUOLEGONGJULIXINGDESHUFU,ZHUANERKAISHIZHIYUE、NAIZHIXINGGOURENLEISHEHUIDEJIBENGUANXIWANGLUOHEZUZHIXINGTAI。SIFATIZHIGAIGESHEJISIFAQUANLIYUNXINGDEDUOGEFANGMIAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANSHISIFAQUANLIYUWANGLUOSHIDAIDEZHIJIEDUIHUA。[6]

秒速赛车6码计划   HULIANWANGJISHUZHISUOYINENGGOUBEISIFALINGYUSUOJIESHOU,GENYUANYUQIZISHENDEYOUYONGXINGYUSHIXIAOXINGNENGGOUQIHEDANGDAIXIQUESIFAZIYUANYUSHEHUIDUISIFAFUWUYUWANGPENGZHANGZHIJIANMAODUNJIAJUBEIJINGXIAMINSHISIFASHIYONGZHUYIDEXIANSHIXUQIU,RANER,HULIANWANGFAYUANYAOCHONGFENFAHUIQIDUI“WANGSHANGANJIAN”BIANJIE、GAOXIAOSHENPANDESIFAXIAONENG,SHOUDANGQICHONGJIUHUIMIANLIN“WANGSHANGANJIAN”ZHENGYISHISHICHAOYUEWULIKONGJIANDIYUDETEXINGYUCHUANTONGMINSHISUSONGYIWULIDIDIANZUOWEILIANJIEDIANQUEDINGGUANXIAFAYUANDESUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEZHIJIANDECHONGTU,RUGUO“WANGSHANGANJIAN”WUFAJINRUHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANSHIYU,YEJIUWUCONGTANJISHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZEDEJIANGOUWENTI。KEJIAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANZUOWEI“HULIANWANG+”ZAISIFATIZHIGAIGEZHONGYUNYONGDEXIANHUOYANGBEN,RUHEBAOZHANGHULIANWANGFAYUANMINSHISUSONGZAISHIXIAN“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DESHENPANMOSHIJICHUSHANG,QUEBAODANGSHIRENYINGYOUSUSONGQUANLIDEHELIXINGSHI,SHIHULIANWANGFAYUANMINSHISUSONGZHENGDANGXINGDEGUANJIAN。RUGUOHULIANWANGFAYUANSUSONGDEDIANZIXINXICHUANDIYUDIANZIFATINGSHENLIBUNENGSHIXIANYUCHUANTONGFAYUANSUSONGZAIBAOZHANGDANGSHIRENSUSONGQUANLIXINGSHIFANGMIANDEDENGJIAGONGNENG,ZEHULIANWANGFAYUANSUSONGDEZHENGDANGXINGHUIZAOSHOUTIAOZHAN,YINCI,HULIANWANGJISHUZAISIFASHENPANZHONGDEYUNYONG,BUKEBIMIANDICHANSHENGHULIANWANGFAYUANZAISHENPANSHEWANGSUSONGANJIANZHONG,HULIANWANGJISHUYUCHUANTONGSUSONGFALVZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEZHIJIANDECHONGTUYURONGHEWENTI。HUANYANZHI,YAOSHIXIANHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANDEZHUANYEHUA,SHEWANGANJIANSUSONGSHENPANBIRANMIANLINCHUANTONGSUSONGFALVZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEDETIAOZHAN。

  二、互聯網法院審判現狀檢視

  HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANZUOWEIZHONGGUOSIFASHIYINGXIANDAIHULIANWANGSHIDAIDEYIXIANGZHONGDASIFAGAIGEYUCHUANGXIN,SHOUDAOLEZHONGGUONAIZHISHIJIEDEZHUMU,YICIWEIYANGBEN,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANYUGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANXIANGJISHELI。DUIYUZHEXIEHANZHU“JINYAOCHI”WENSHI,CHENGZAIZHUGAOCENGQIDAIYUSHEHUIGEJIEGUANZHUDESIFACHONGER,ZAISHIXIAN“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANYEHUASHENPANGONGNENGDEGUOCHENGZHONG,JIUJINGMIANLINCHUANTONGSUSONGFALVZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEDEHEZHONGTIAOZHAN,YINGRUHEJIANGOUSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZEBINGWANSHANSHENLIJIZHI?

秒速赛车6码计划   (YI)HULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANYANGBENFENXI

  1.HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANYANGBENFENXI

  TONGGUOAlphaFALVZHINENGJIANSUOXITONG,JIEZHIDAO2019NIAN7YUE27RI,BIZHEYI“HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN”WEIJIANSUODUIXIANG、YI“MINSHIANJIAN”WEIANJIANLEIXING、YI“2017NIANZHI2019NIAN”WEISHIJIANFANWEI、YI“SHENLICHENGXU(YISHEN)”WEISHENJI,GONGJIANSUOCHU2539FENCAIPANWENSHU,QIZHONGPANJUE369FEN、CAIDING1875FEN、DIAOJIESHU295FEN。KEJIAN,ZAIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIZHIBIZHEJIANSUOJIEZHIDEJINLIANGNIANSHIJIANLI,YOUHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHOULIBINGZUOCHUCHULIDE2539FENCAIPANWENSHUZHONG,YIPANJUEHUOZHEDIAOJIESHUFANGSHIZUOCHUSHITICHULIDECAIPANWENSHUGONGYOU664FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE26.2%;ERYICAIDINGFANGSHIZUOCHUCHENGXUXINGCHULIDEZEYOU1875FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE73.8%,QIZHONG,YOU11FENBOHUIQISUDECAIDING、145FENBUYUSHOULIDECAIDING、22FENGUANXIAQUANYIYIDECAIDING,3ZHESANZHONGCAIDINGGONGJI58FEN,ZHANCAIDINGZONGSHUDE3.1%;QIYU1817FENCAIDINGJUNWEIZHUNXUCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULIDECAIDING,4ZHANCAIDINGZONGSHUDE96.9%。ZAISHANGSHUCAIDINGZHONG,YOUWEISHUBUSHAODECAIDINGCHENGXIANCHUBEIGAOTONGYIDE“CHUANAN”TEDIAN,JIDUOGEYUANGAOFENBIEDUITONGYIGEBEIGAOTIQISUSONGBIAODEWEITONGYIZHONGLEIDESUSONGANJIAN,RUDUOGEYUANGAOYIHANGZHOUYICHENGKEJIYOUXIANGONGSIWEIBEIGAOTIQIDEWANGLUOGOUWUHETONGJIUFENSUSONG、DUOGEYUANGAOYIZHEJIANGTAOBAOWANGLUOYOUXIANGONGSIWEIBEIGAOTIQIDEWANGLUOGOUWUHETONGJIUFENHUOZHECHANPINZERENJIUFENSUSONG、DUOGEYUANGAOYIGUANGZHOUCHENLONGJIAOYUKEJIYOUXIANGONGSIWEIBEIGAOTIQIDEQINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFENSUSONGDENG,ERQIEZAISHANGSHU“CHUANAN”SUSONGZHONGHUANYOUSHUSHIQISHENZHISHANGBAIQIANJIANSHENQINGCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULI。

秒速赛车6码计划   ZAIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSUOZUOCHUDE2FENGUANYUGUANXIAQUANYIYIDECAIDINGZHONG,JUNYIBEIGAODEGUANXIAQUANYIYILIYOUCHENGLI,CAIDINGYISONGGUANXIA。RUZAIHAIKESIKANGRUANJIANJISHU(QINGDAO)YOUXIANGONGSI、ZUOXINGWANG、ZHEJIANGTAOBAOWANGLUOYOUXIANGONGSIQINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFENYIANZHONG,HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANJINGSHENCHARENWEI:“CONGYUANGAOQISUZHUANGSUOSHUSHISHIJIQITIJIAODEZHENGJUCAILIAOCHUBUPANDUAN,BENANXIZHENDUITEDINGZUOPINKETIJIJISUANJIRUANJIANQINHAIERCHANSHENGDEZHUZUOQUANQINQUANJIUFEN,GUGENJU《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANMINSHIANJIANANYOUGUIDING》,BENANANYOUYINGQUEDINGWEIQINHAIJISUANJIRUANJIANZHUZUOQUANJIUFEN。TONGSHI,JINGZUIGAORENMINFAYUANPIZHUN,ZHEJIANGSHENGHANGZHOUSHIZHONGJIRENMINFAYUANZI2017NIAN9YUE8RIQIGUANXIAFASHENGZAIHANGZHOUSHI、JIAXINGSHI、HUZHOUSHI、JINHUASHI、QUZHOUSHI、LISHUISHIXIAQUNEIYOUGUANZHUANLI、JISHUMIMI、JISUANJIRUANJIAN、ZHIWUXINPINZHONG、JICHENGDIANLUBUTUSHEJI、SHEJICHIMINGSHANGBIAORENDINGJILONGDUANJIUFENDEDIYISHENZHISHICHANQUANMINSHIANJIANDENG。YINCI,BENANYUANGAOHAIKESIKANGGONGSITIQIDEQINHAIJISUANJIRUANJIANZHUZUOQUANJIUFENZHISU,BENYUANBINGWUGUANXIAQUAN,ERSHUYUZHEJIANGSHENGHANGZHOUSHIZHONGJIRENMINFAYUANYOUQUANGUANXIADETEDINGANJIANLEIXING,YINGDANGYISONGZHIZHEJIANGSHENGHANGZHOUSHIZHONGJIRENMINFAYUANSHENLI。”5CIWAI,ZAIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANZUOCHUDE45FENBUYUSHOULIDECAIDINGZHONG,FAYUANBUYUSHOULIDELIYOUZHUYAOYESHIDUIYUANGAOQISUDEANJIANMEIYOUGUANXIAQUAN。RUZAICHENJIANBO、SHENZHENSHIHEFANGKEJIKAIFAYOUXIANGONGSIWANGLUOGOUWUHETONGJIUFENANZHONG,FAYUANRENWEI:“GENJUQISURENCHENJIANBOTIGONGDEZHENGJU,BEIQISURENSHENZHENSHIHEFANGKEJIKAIFAYOUXIANGONGSIDEZHUSUODIJIBENANHETONGLVXINGDI,JUNBUZAIZHEJIANGSHENGHANGZHOUDIQU,BUSHUYUBENYUANGUANXIAFANWEI,GUBENYUANDUIBENANBUJUYOUGUANXIAQUAN”,YINCI,FAYUANCAIDINGBUYUSHOULIANJIAN。6YOUCIKEJIAN,JISHISHEWANGANJIANYEYOUKENENGYINWEIANJIANXINGZHI,YIHUOSHOUXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFAYIXIANSHIKONGJIANLIDEWULIDIDIANZUOWEILIANJIEDIANSUOQUELIDEDIYUGUANXIAZHIDUDEZHIYUEERSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANWUQUANGUANXIA。

秒速赛车6码计划   CIWAI,FENXIJIANSUODAODECAIPANWENSHUZUOCHUDESHIJIAN,HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCHENGLIYU2017NIAN8YUE18RI,CHENGLIDANGYUEJIZUOCHU3FENCAIPANWENSHU,9YUEXIAOFUZENGJIAZHI75FEN,10YUEYOUXIAOFUXIAJIANGZHI45FEN,ZHIHOUCHUXIANJIZENG,11YUETUZENGZHI198FEN,ER12YUEGENGSHIFANBEIZENGZHI530FEN。2018NIAN1-4YUEZHIJIANXIAOFUHUILUO,JIBENWEICHIZAI274-409FENZHIJIAN,QIZHONG,1YUE295FEN、2YUE277FEN、3YUESHULIANGZUIDUOWEI409FEN、4YUEWEI274FEN,DANZI5YUEKAISHITURANDUANYASHIXIAJIANGZHI5YUE1FEN、6YUE2FENYU7YUE1FEN,ZI8YUEKAISHISHANGZHANG,ZHI12YUECHENGXIANCHUQIAN“V”ZIXINGDEZHUANGTAI,JI8YUE28FEN、9YUE8FEN、10YUE3FEN、11YUE11FEN、12YUE22FEN。2019NIAN1YUEZHI3YUEJIBENPINGWEN,JI1YUE15FEN、2YUE10FENYU3YUE16FEN,CIHOUKAISHICHENGXIANCHULIANJIANSHULIANGZHUJIANSHANGSHENGDEQUSHI,JI4YUE22FEN、5YUE38FEN,DAO6YUEDAFUSHANGSHENGZHI203FEN,7YUEZHIJIANSUOJIEZHIRIWEI63FEN。RUXIATUYISUOSHI:

圖一 杭州互聯網法院裁判文書
圖一 杭州互聯網法院裁判文書

  YOUSHANGTUKEJIAN,HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCHULIANJIANDESHULIANGCHENGXIANCHUBUWENDING、SHENZHIBODONGJIAODADEQINGKUANG。ZONGTIERYAN,HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANZI2017NIAN8YUESHELIZHI2019NIAN7YUEDELIANGNIANSHIJIANLIGONGZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHU2539FEN,PINGJUNMEIYUEZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHU106FEN,YUWOGUODANGQIANJICENGRENMINFAYUANANDUORENSHAO、“RENANBI”MAODUNTUCHUDESIFAXIANZHUANGXIANGBI,SHENPANANJIANDESHULIANGXIANGDUIJIAOSHAO。

秒速赛车6码计划   2.BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANYANGBENFENXI

秒速赛车6码计划   TONGGUOAlphaFALVZHINENGJIANSUOXITONG,JIEZHIDAO2019NIAN7YUE27RI,BIZHEYI“BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUAN”WEIJIANSUODUIXIANG、YI“MINSHIANJIAN”WEIANJIANLEIXING、YI“2018NIANHE2019NIAN”WEISHIJIANFANWEI、YI“SHENLICHENGXU(YISHEN)”WEISHENJI ,GONGJIANSUOCHU5114FENCAIPANWENSHU,QIZHONGPANJUE420FEN、CAIDING3268FEN、DIAOJIESHU1426FEN。SHANGSHUCAIPANWENSHUZHONG,YOU2129FENCAIDINGNEIRONGWEIGONGKAI,WUFAHUOZHIBINGFENXIZHEXIECAIDINGDEJUTINEIRONG,YINCI,KEYIYOUXIAOZUOWEIFENXIYANGBENDECAIPANWENSHUGONGJI2985FEN。KEJIAN,ZIBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIZHIBIZHEJIANSUOJIEZHIDE10GEYUELI,YOUBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANSHOULIBINGZUOCHUCHULIDE5114FENCAIPANWENSHUZHONG,YIPANJUEHUOZHEDIAOJIESHUFANGSHIZUOCHUSHITICHULIDECAIPANWENSHUGONGYOU1846FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE36.1%;ERYICAIDINGFANGSHIZUOCHUCHENGXUXINGCHULIDEZEYOU3268FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE63.9%。ZAIGONGKAIDE1139FENCAIDINGZHONG,SHEJIGUANXIAQUANYIYIDECAIDINGYOU78FEN,7ZHANGONGKAICAIDINGZONGSHUDE6.8%;BOHUIQISUDECAIDINGZHIYOU5FEN,8ZHANGONGKAICAIDINGZONGSHUDE0.4%;BUZHENGPANJUESHUBIWUDECAIDINGYOU8FEN,9ZHANGONGKAICAIDINGZONGSHUDE0.7%;QIYUJUNWEIZHUNXUCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULIDECAIDING,10GONGJI1048FEN,ZHANGONGKAICAIDINGZONGSHUDE92%。QIZHONG,SHEJIGUANXIAQUANYIYIDE78FENCAIDINGZHONG,YOU69FENCAIDINGRENWEIBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANYOUGUANXIAQUANERCAIDINGBOHUIBEIGAODEGUANXIAQUANYIYI,DANSHI,YOU9FENCAIDINGZEYIBEIGAOGUANXIAQUANYIYILIYOUCHENGLI,CAIDINGYISONGGUANXIA。LIRU,ZAILISHENGBINYUBEIJINGZHIRONGSHIDAIXINXIJISHUYOUXIANGONGSIWANGLUOQINQUANZERENJIUFENYIANZHONG,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANRENWEI“BENANYUANGAOZHUZHANGBEIGAOTONGGUOYUYINDIANHUA、DUANXINDUIYUANGAOJINXINGSAORAO,YAOQIUBEIGAOCHENGDANQINQUANZEREN,YUANGAOZAIBENANZHUZHANGDEQINQUANXINGWEIBINGFEITONGGUOHULIANWANGJINXING,BENYUANDUIBENANWUGUANXIAQUAN。YINQINQUANXINGWEITIQIDESUSONG,YOUQINQUANXINGWEIDIHUOZHEBEIGAOZHUSUODIRENMINFAYUANGUANXIA,BENANKEYOUBEIGAOZHUSUODIRENMINFAYUANJIBEIJINGSHIHAIDIANQURENMINFAYUANSHENLI。”11

  CIWAI,YUHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANBEIGAOTONGYIDE“CHUANAN”YOUSUOBUTONG,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANDE“CHUANAN”DADUOBIAOXIANWEIYUANGAOTONGYI,JITONGYIYUANGAODUIBUTONGBEIGAOTIQISUSONGBIAODEWEITONGYIZHONGLEIDESHUSHIQI、SHENZHISHANGBAIQISUSONG,RUYOUBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSI、LANNIUZIYINGXIANG(BEIJING)YOUXIANGONGSI、JIANGSUYANGZIWANBAOYOUXIANGONGSI、GUANGZHOUALIBABAWENXUEXINXIJISHUYOUXIANGONGSIDENGJIJIAGONGSIFENBIEZUOWEIYUANGAOJIUGEZITIQILEDUOQIZHUZUOQUANQUANSHU、QINQUANJIUFENSUSONG,BINGQIEQIZHONGFENBIEYOUSHUSHIQI、SHENZHISHANGBAIQIANJIANSHISHENQINGCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULIDE。

秒速赛车6码计划   JIUJIANSUODAODECAIPANWENSHUZUOCHUDESHIJIANLAIKAN,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANCHENGLIYU2018NIAN9YUE9RI,CHENGLIDANGYUEJISHENLIYIQIANJIANBINGZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHU,10YUEXIAOFUSHANGSHENGZHI41FENCAIPANWENSHU,DAO11YUEYU12YUEFENBIEXUNSUZENGJIADAO799FENYU962FENCAIPANWENSHU。RANER,ZAIJINGLILIANGGEYUECHULIANJIANSHULIANGDEDAFUDUKUAISUZENGCHANGHOU,2019NIAN1YUEZHI6YUECHULIANJIANSHULIANGQUECHENGXIANCHU“W”ZIXINGDEJIAODABODONGZHUANGTAI,1YUEYU2YUEFENBIEJIAODAFUDUXIAJIANGWEI269FENYU468FENCAIPANWENSHU,3YUEYOUKUAISUSHENGZHI997FEN,DAN4YUEYU5YUEYOUFENBIEXUNSUHUILUOZHI172FENYU367FENCAIPANWENSHU,DAO6YUEYOUTURANCHUXIANYIGE951FENCAIPANWENSHUDEGAOFENG,7YUEFENJIEZHIDAOBIZHEJIANSUOZHIRIYOU87FENCAIPANWENSHU。RUXIATUERSUOSHI:

圖二 北京互聯網法院裁判文書
秒速赛车6码计划 圖二 北京互聯網法院裁判文書

秒速赛车6码计划   YOUSHANGTUKEJIAN,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANCHULIANJIANDESHULIANGCHENGXIANCHUBUWENDING,SHENZHIBODONGJIAODADEQINGKUANG。ZONGTIERYAN,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIHOUDE10GEYUENEIGONGZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHU5114FEN,PINGJUNMEIYUE511FEN。XIANGBIJIAOHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN,SUIRANBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIDESHIJIANJIAODUAN,DANJIUQIZUOCHUDECAIPANWENSHUERYAN,BUJINSHULIANGYUANDUOYUHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN,ERQIESUOZUOCHUDECAIDINGLEIXINGXIANGDUIDUOYANG,JIBENFUGAILEFAYUANDUISUSONGANJIANJINXINGCHENGXUCHULISUOSHEJIDEZHUYAOLEIXINGDECAIDING。

  3.GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANYANGBENFENXI

秒速赛车6码计划   TONGGUOAlphaFALVZHINENGJIANSUOXITONG,JIEZHIDAO2019NIAN7YUE27RI,YI“GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN”WEIJIANSUODUIXIANG、YI“MINSHIANJIAN”WEIANJIANLEIXING、YI“2018NIANHE2019NIAN”WEISHIJIANFANWEI、YI“SHENLICHENGXU(YISHEN)”WEISHENJI,GONGJIANSUOCHU6814FENCAIPANWENSHU,QIZHONGPANJUE71FEN,CAIDING6743FEN。KEJIAN,ZIGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIZHIJIANSUOJIEZHIDE10GEYUESHIJIAN,YOUGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHOULIBINGZUOCHUCHULIDE6814FENCAIPANWENSHUZHONG,YIPANJUEFANGSHIZUOCHUSHITICHULIDECAIPANWENSHUZHIYOU71FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE1.04%;ERYICAIDINGFANGSHIZUOCHUCHENGXUXINGCHULIDEZEYOU6743FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE98.96%。CIWAI,6743FENCAIDINGBUJINQUANBUSHIZHUNXUCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULI,12ERQIESUOSHEJIDEANJIANZHONGLEIXIANGDUIDANYI,CHENGXIANCHUFEICHANGTUCHUDEYUANGAOJUYOUTONGYIXINGDE“CHUANAN”TEDIAN,QIZHONG,JINZHONGYOUXIAOFEIJINRONGYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOJIUFENBIEYITANGJIANGSHENG、WANGJINHUIDENG6222RENWEIBEIGAOQISULE6222QIJINRONGJIEKUANHETONGJIUFENAN,QIEFAYUANJUNZUOCHUZHUNXUCHESUDECAIDING,ZHANCAIDINGZONGSHUDE92.27%;YIBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOQISUDEQINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFENANJIANZHONGZUOCHUDECHESUCAIDINGYOU51FEN,ZHANCAIDINGZONGSHUDE0.8%;JIYUQITAGEZHUTIQISU,FAYUANZUOCHUZHUNXUCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULIDECAIDINGZHIYOU470FEN,ZHANCAIDINGZONGSHUDE6.93%。

秒速赛车6码计划   CIWAI,FENXIJIANSUODAODECAIPANWENSHUZUOCHUDESHIJIAN,GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANYU2018NIAN9YUE28RICHENGLI,2018NIAN10YUEZUOCHUDECAIPANWENSHUJINWEI2FEN,DAO11YUEDAFUDUZENGJIAZHI194FEN,CIHOUDE12YUEZHI2019NIAN2YUEYOUJIAODAFUDUXIAJIANGWEI60FEN、72FENYU55FEN,ZI2019NIAN3YUEKAISHIWENBUSHANGSHENGWEI3YUEDE97FENHE4YUEDE109FEN,ER5YUETURANZHIXIANXINGBAOZENGZHI6225FEN,DAN6YUEZEDUANYASHIZOUJIANGWEI0FEN,JIEZHIDAOBIZHEJIANSUORIDE7YUEFENWEI0FEN。RUXIATUSANSUOSHI:

圖三 廣州互聯網法院裁判文書
圖三 廣州互聯網法院裁判文書

  YOUSHANGTUKEJIAN,JIUGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCHULIANJIANDESHULIANGERYAN,HEBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANYUHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCHULIANJIANSHULIANGCHENGXIANCHUBUWENDING、SHENZHIBODONGJIAODADEZHUANGKUANGWANQUANBUTONG,GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCHULIANJIANDESHULIANGZAI2019NIAN4YUEZHIQIANCHENGXIANCHUSHULIANGSHAO、QIEXIANGDUIWENDINGZHONGLVEYOUBODONGDETAISHI,ER2019NIAN5YUEZHI7YUEZECHENGXIANCHUZHIXIANXINGBAOZENGHUOZHEDUANYASHIZOUJIANGWEI0DEDAQIDALUOZHUANGTAI。ZONGTIERYAN,GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCHENGLIHOUDE10GEYUEZHIZHONG,SUIRANCONGZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHUDESHULIANGLAIKAN,JUYUSANGEHULIANWANGFAYUANZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHUSHULIANGDEDIYIWEI,RANER,RUGUOTICHU2019NIAN5YUEDUIZHONGYOUXIAOFEIJINRONGYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOFENBIEDUI6222MINGBEIGAOTIQIDE6222QISUSONGANJIANZUOCHUDECHESUCAIDING,GUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANZAICHENGLIDE10GEYUESHIJIANLISHIJISHANGZHIZUOCHULE592FENCAIPANWENSHU,MEIYUEPINGJUNZHIYOU59FEN,YUGUANGZHOUZHEYANGYIGESHICHANGJINGJIFADA,MINSHANGSHIANJIANSHULIANGDUO,JICENGRENMINFAYUAN“RENANBI”MAODUNGENGJIATUCHUDIFANGDESIFAXIANZHUANGGEGEBURU。

秒速赛车6码计划   (ER)HULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANKUNJING

  TONGGUOFENBIEDUIHANGZHOU、BEIJINGHEGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANWENSHUYANGBENSHULIGUINAKEYIKANCHU,SANDAHULIANWANGFAYUANDEMINSHISHENPANCHENGXIANCHUMINGXIANTEDIAN,QIEMIANLINYIDINGDESHENPANKUNJING。

秒速赛车6码计划   1.CHENGXUXINGCHULIYIJICHESUANJIANSHULIANGJUYUJUEDUIYOUSHI,ZHIYUEQIZHUANYEHUASHENPANGONGNENGZHISHIXIAN。CONGBIZHEDUISUOJIANSUODEHULIANWANGFAYUANZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHUDESHULIYUGUINAQINGKUANGLAIKAN,SANGEHULIANWANGFAYUANGONGJIZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHU14467FEN。QIZHONG,PANJUE860FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE5.9%;DIAOJIESHU1721FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE11.9%;CAIDING11886FEN,ZHANCAIPANWENSHUZONGSHUDE82.2%。YEJIUSHISHUO,ZAIHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENLIBINGZUOCHUCHULIDEANJIANZHONG,YIPANJUE、DIAOJIESHUFANGSHIDUIANJIANTONGGUOSHITICHULIJIEJUESHEWANGJIUFENDEANJIANSHULIANGZAIANJIANZONGSHULIANGZHONGJINZHAN17.8%,BINGQIEZUOCHUDEPANJUEZHIYOUBUDAODIAOJIESHUSHULIANGDEYIBAN,ERDUIYU82.2%DEANJIAN,FAYUANDOUSHICONGCHENGXUSHANGZUOCHUDECHULI,ZHEJIUYIWEIZHU,HULIANWANGFAYUANCONGSHELIZHIJIN,ZUOWEIDUISHEWANGJIUFENANJIANJIZHONGGUANXIADETESHUFAYUAN,QIZHENZHENGDUIDANGSHIRENZHIJIANDESHEWANGANJIANTONGGUOSHITISHENLIZUOCHUPANJUEDEANJIANSHULIANGSHIJIAOSHAODE。CIWAI,ZAIHULIANWANGFAYUANDUIANJIANZUOCHUCHENGXUCHULIDE11886FENCAIDINGZHONG,QUCHUHULIANWANGFAYUANWEIGONGKAIDE2129FENCAIDING,ZAI9757FENGONGKAICAIDINGZHONG,FAYUANZUOCHUDEZHUNXUCHESUYUANCHESUCHULIDECAIDINGGONGJI9608FEN,ZHANGONGKAICAIDINGZONGSHUDE98.5%。FAYUANCAIDINGZHUNXUDANGSHIRENCHESUSHENQINGDEZHUYAOLIYOUSHIDANGSHIRENSHENQINGCHESUFUHEFALVGUIDINGHUOZHEDANGSHIRENYINDACHENGHEJIEXIEYIERSHENQINGCHESU,FAYUANCAIDINGANCHESUCHULIDABUFENSHIYINWEIYUANGAOWEIANSHIJIAONASUSONGFEIYONG,SHAOSHUSHIYINWEIYUANGAOJINGFAYUANCHUANPIAOCHUANHUAN,WUZHENGDANGLIYOUBUDAOTINGCANJIASUSONG。YOUCIKEJIAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANDUIYUSUOSHOULIDEANJIAN,JUEDADUOSHUSHICONGCHENGXUSHANGZUOCHUCHULI,QIECAIDINGZHUNXUCHESUHUOZHEANCHESUCHULIDEANJIANZHANJUEDUIYOUSHI。SHENSHENFENXIHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANXIANZHUANGBUJINLINGRENDANYOU,HULIANWANGFAYUANZUOWEIZHONGGUOSIFASHIYINGXIANDAIHULIANWANGSHIDAIDEYIXIANGZHONGDASIFAGAIGECUOSHI,BUJINXIYINLEGUORENYIJISHIJIEDEZHUMU,ERQIECHENGZAIZHUGUOJIA、MINZHONGYIJIXUESHULILUNJIEDEQIWANG,RANER,MUQIANHULIANWANGFAYUANZAITONGGUOPANJUEJIEJUESHEWANGANJIANFANGMIANSHULIANGYOUXIAN,HENNANTIXIANQISHENPANDEGAOXIAOLV,GENGNANYISHIXIANQISUOCHENGZAIDE“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANYEHUASHENPANDESIFAZEREN。

  2.ANJIANLEIXINGJIZHONGQIECHENGXIANCHUMINGXIANDE“CHUANAN”TEDIAN,YUMINSUZHIDUXIANGCHONGTU。CONGBIZHEDUIJIANSUOCAIPANWENSHUDEFENXILAIKAN,WULUNSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANYIPANJUEHUOZHEDIAOJIEFANGSHIJIEJUEJIUFENDEANJIAN,HUANSHIYICAIDINGDEFANGSHIZUOCHUCHENGXUCHULIDEANJIAN,SUOSHEJIDEANJIANLEIXINGZHUYAOJIZHONGYUWANGLUOGOUWUHETONGJIUFEN、JINRONGJIEKUANHETONGJIUFEN、WANGLUOFUWUHETONGJIUFEN、ZHUZUOQUANQUANSHUYUQINQUANJIUFEN、QINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFENZHEWUZHONGLEIXINGDEANJIAN。QIZHONG,WANGLUOGOUWUHETONGJIUFENDADUOWEIYUANGAOSHIZIRANRENDEANJIAN,JINRONGJIEKUANHETONGJIUFENZEDADUOWEIBEIGAOSHIZIRANRENDEANJIAN,ZHELIANGLEIYIZIRANRENWEIYIFANGDANGSHIRENDESHEWANGMINSHIJIUFENSHIJISHANGSHIWOGUOHULIANWANGGOUWUYUHULIANWANGJINRONGFAZHANDECHANWU;ERZHUZUOQUANQUANSHUYUQINQUANJIUFEN、QINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFENZEDADUOWEISHUANGFANGSHIGONGSIDEANJIAN,ZHEYEFANYINGCHUHULIANWANGSHIDAIDUIZHUZUOQUANQUANSHUJIEDINGYIJIZHUZUOQUANBAOHUTICHULEXINDEYAOQIU。CIWAI,HULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANDEANJIANCHENGXIANCHUMINGXIANDETONGYIYUANGAOQISUDUOGEBEIGAO,HUOZHEDUOGEYUANGAOFENBIEQISUTONGYIBEIGAO,QIESUSONGBIAODESHUYUTONGYIZHONGLEIDE“CHUANAN”TEDIAN,QIZHONG,ZUIWEIDIANXINGDESHIGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENLIDEZHONGYOUXIAOFEIJINRONGYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOFENBIEQISU6222GEZIRANRENDE6222QIJINRONGJIEKUANJIUFEN“CHUANAN”,ZHEYIFANGMIANFANYINGLESHEWANGMINSHIJIUFENYUCHUANTONGMINSHIJIUFENDECHAYIXING,JIYUCHUANTONGMINSHANGSHIJIAOWANGSHOUXIANYUKONGJIANDIYUDEYINGXIANGBUTONG,SHEHULIANWANGMINSHANGSHIJIAOWANGSUOJUYOUDECHAOYUEKONGJIANDIYUYINGXIANGDEYOUSHI,ZAIJIDADIZENGJIALEMINSHANGSHIFALVGUANXISHELI、BIANGENGYUXIAOMIEBIANJIEXINGDETONGSHI,YESHIDEMEIYIGEJIEZHUHULIANWANGPINGTAICONGSHIMAOYI、JINRONG、FUWUDENGHUODONGDEGONGSIKEYIBIANLIDIMIANDUIQUANGUOGEDISHENZHIHAINEIWAIDEWUSHUGEJIAOYIHUOBAN;TONGSHI,YEFANYINGCHUHULIANWANGFAYUANZAICHULISHEWANGMINSHIJIUFENANJIANSHISHIYONGMINSHISUSONGFASUOGUIDINGDEPUTONGGONGTONGSUSONGYIJIDAIBIAORENSUSONGZHIDUDEXIAOJIXING,YETIXIANLEXIANDAISHEWANGMINSHIJIUFENSUSONGYUCHUANTONGMINSHISUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEZHIJIANDECHONGTUYURONGHEWENTI。

秒速赛车6码计划   3.TONGYIYUANGAOFENBIEXIANGBUTONGHULIANWANGFAYUANTIQIDUOQI“CHUANAN”SUSONG,BULIYUCAIPANTONGYI。CONGBIZHEDUIJIANSUOSANDAHULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANWENSHUDEHENGXIANGSHULILAIKAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANDE“CHUANAN”ZHONG,CUNZAIYITONGYIZHUTIWEIYUANGAOYIFANGDANGSHIRENDESHANGBAIQISHEWANGMINSHIJIUFEN,YOUYUBEIGAOZHUSUODIDECHAYIERXIANGBUTONGHULIANWANGFAYUANQISUDEXIANXIANG,RUZAIBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANDEANJIANZHONG,YOUSHANGBAIQIYOUBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOQISUDEZHUZUOQUANQUANSHU、QINQUANJIUFENANJIAN;ERZAIGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANDEANJIANZHONG,YOUYOUSHANGBAIQIYOUBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOQISUDEQINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFENANJIAN。SUIRANTONGGUOAlphaFALVZHINENGJIANSUOXITONGZAIBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANWENSHUZHONGJIANSUODAODEYOUGUANBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOQISUDEANJIAN,ANYOUWEI“ZHUZUOQUANQUANSHUQINQUANJIUFEN”,DANSHIFAYUANCAIDINGZHONGGUANYUYUANGAOQISUSHISHIYULIYOUDEJIZAIZHONG,JUNXUSHUWEI:“YUANGAORENWEIBEIGAOZAIMEIYOUDEDAOSHOUQUANDEQINGKUANGXIA,SHANZISHIYONGSHEANSHEYINGZUOPINDEXINGWEIYIJINGWEIFAN《ZHONGHUARENMINGONGHEGUOZHUZUOQUANFA》DI47、49TIAOJIQITATIAOKUANZHIGUIDING,QINFANLEYUANGAODUISHEANSHEYINGZUOPINXIANGYOUDEXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANDENGZHUZUOQUANQUANLI,BINGGEIYUANGAOZAOCHENGLEJIAODADEJINGJISUNSHI”,13KEJIAN,YUANGAOQISUSUOWEIHUDESHIJISHIBEIQINFANDEQISHEYINGZUOPINXIANGYOUDEXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUAN。ERTONGGUOAlphaFALVZHINENGJIANSUOXITONGZAIGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANCAIPANWENSHUZHONGJIANSUODAODEYOUGUANBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAOQISUDEANJIANZHONG,FAYUANCAIDINGSUOJIZAIDEANYOUSHI“QINHAIZUOPINXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANJIUFEN”,YINCAIDINGZHONGJINZHIJIEXIEMINGYUANGAOSHENQINGCHESU,ERWEIJIZAIYUANGAOQISUDESUSONGQINGQIUYIJISHISHIYULIYOU,14DAOZHIBIZHEWUFAPANDUANYUANGAOBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZAIGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANQISUDEANJIANYUZAIBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANQISUDEANJIAN,SHIFOUJUNJIYUQISHEYINGZUOPINXIANGYOUDEXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANBEIBUTONGBEIGAOQINHAIDESHISHI。CONGXIANYOUCAIPANWENSHUDEQINGKUANGLAIKAN,BUPAICHUBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIJIYUQISHEYINGZUOPINXIANGYOUDEXINXIWANGLUOCHUANBOQUANBEIDUOGEBUTONGBEIGAOQINHAI,ERYINDUOGEBEIGAOZHUSUODIHUOZHEQINQUANXINGWEIDIBUTONG,ERBUDEYIXIANGBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANHEGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANFENBIEQISUDEQINGKUANG,SHENZHIHUANKENENGCUNZAIXIANGBEIGAOZHUSUODIHUOZHEQINQUANXINGWEIDIDEQITADIQUDEFEIHULIANWANGFAYUANQISUDEQINGKUANG。ZHISUOYICHUXIANZHEYIXIANXIANG,SHIYINWEIHULIANWANGJIAOYIBUTONGYUCHUANTONGJIAOYI,QISUOJUYOUDECHAOYUEKONGJIANDIYUXINGYIJIJISHIBIANJIEXING,SHIDEJIEZHUHULIANWANGPINGTAICONGSHISHANGSHIHUODONGDEYIGEZHUTIMIANDUIBUTONGDIQUSHUYIWANJIDEJIAOYIDUIXIANGCHENGWEIXIANSHI,ZHEJIUBIRANKENENGCHANSHENGJUDASHULIANGDEZHUTIYUTONGYIJIEZHUHULIANWANGPINGTAICONGSHISHANGSHIHUODONGDEZHUTIFASHENGMINSHIJIUFEN。DUIYUJIANSUODAODEBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIFENBIEXIANGBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANHEGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANQISUDESHANGBAIQIANJIAN,RUGUOBUSHIBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIJUNYIFASHENQINGCHESU,HENNANYUCE,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANHEGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANFENBIEDUISHANGBAIQITONGYIYUANGAOQISUDEANJIANJINGGUOSHITISHENLIHOUZUOCHUDEPANJUE,NENGFOUYINTONGYIBAWOCAIPANCHIDUERZUODAO“LEIANLEIPAN”。

  三、互聯網法院審判困境之理論分析

  HULIANWANGFAYUANZAIYIJIEJUECHUANTONGFEIWANGSHANGMINSHIJIUFENWEIJICHUDESUSONGLILUNZHIDAOXIAXINGCHENGDEMINSHISUSONGLIFAKUANGJIANEIYUNXING,NANMIANHUIMIANLINZHIDUXINGZHANGAI,YINCI,TANSUOSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZECHENGWEIHULIANWANGFAYUANSHIXIANQIZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENGDEBIRANYAOQIU,ERJIANGOUJUTISUSONGGUIZEDEQIANTIZESHIHELIQUEDINGHULIANWANGFAYUANGUANXIAANJIANDEFANWEIWENTI。SHENSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANCUNZAIDEXIANSHIKUNJING,KEYIKANCHU,XIANXINGMINSHISUSONGLIFANANYISHIYINGHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANWANGSHANGANJIANDEXUYAO。

  (YI)SHEWANGANJIANKUADIYUXINGYUMINSHISUSONGGUANXIAZHIDUXIANGCHONGTU

秒速赛车6码计划   SHEHULIANWANGANJIANYOUYUQIMINSHIFALVGUANXISHELI、BIANGENGHUOZHEXIAOMIEDESHISHIYIJIYUCIXIANGGUANDEZILIAOFASHENGHUOZHECUNCHUYUHULIANWANGZHIZHONG,CILEIMINSHIANJIANDESHENPAN,JIULIAN、SUSONGZILIAODETIJIAO、ZHENGJUJIAOHUAN、SUSONGWENSHUSONGDADENGSUSONGCHENGXUHUANJIEERYAN,XIANDAIXIANSHANGSUSONGYUCHUANTONGXIANXIASUSONGXIANGBIJIAO,CHULEZILIAOZAITIDESHUZIHUAYIJIDIANZICHUANDIFANGSHIDEJISHIXINGSUODAILAIDECHENGXUBIANJIE、SHENPANGAOXIAOYIWAI,BINGWUSHIZHICHAYI。RANER,ZAIWANGSHANGZHENGJUDESHOUJI、BAOQUAN、ZHIZHENG、RENZHENGDENGYINGXIANGDAOANJIANSHISHIRENDINGDEGUANJIANSUSONGHUANJIE,SHEHULIANWANGANJIANDEXIANDAIXIANSHANGSUSONGQUEJUYOUCHUANTONGXIANXIASUSONGWANQUANBUTONGDEDUTEXINGYUZHUANYEXING。WEICI,DIANZISHANGWUDEXUNMENGFAZHANGEIXIANDAISIFATICHULEBIANJIEHUAYUZHUANYEHUADESHENPANXUQIU。XIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFAYIJIXIANGGUANSIFAJIESHIHUIYINGXINGDIZUOCHULEYIXIEGUIDING,RU2012NIAN《MINSHISUSONGFA》(DIERCIXIUZHENG)DI63TIAOJIANGDIANZISHUJUZUOWEIDULIZHENGJUZHONGLEIYUYIQUELI,2015NIAN《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGUANYUSHIYONG<ZHONGHUARENMINGONGHEGUOMINSHISUSONGFA>DEJIESHI》(YIXIAJIANCHENG《MINSUFAJIESHI》)DI20TIAOGUIDINGLEHULIANWANGMAIMAIHETONGJIUFENDEGUANXIAQUEDING,JIYIXINXIWANGLUOFANGSHIDINGLIDEMAIMAIHETONG,TONGGUOXINXIWANGLUOFANGSHIJIAOFUBIAODEDE,YIMAISHOURENZHUSUODIWEIHETONGLVXINGDI;TONGGUOQITAFANGSHIJIAOFUBIAODEDE,SHOUHUODIWEIHETONGLVXINGDI。HETONGDUILVXINGDIYOUYUEDINGDE,CONGQIYUEDING。CIWAI,GAISIFAJIESHIDI25TIAOYEGUIDINGLESHEHULIANWANGQINQUANJIUFENDEGUANXIAQUEDING,JIXINXIWANGLUOQINQUANXINGWEISHISHIDIBAOKUOSHISHIBEISUQINQUANXINGWEIDEJISUANJIDENGXINXISHEBEISUOZAIDI,QINQUANJIEGUOFASHENGDIBAOKUOBEIQINQUANRENZHUSUODI。ZHEXIEGUIDINGBIAOMIANSHANGTIXIANLESHEWANGANJIANGUANXIAQUEDINGDETESHUXING,DANJIEHESHEWANGSHANGSHIJIAOYIDECHAOYUEKONGJIANDIYUXINGTEDIAN,BUNANFAXIAN,XIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFASUOQUELIDEDIYUGUANXIAZHIDUZHIYUELEHULIANWANGFAYUAN“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENPAN”ZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENGDEFAHUI。ZHUYAOCUNZAIYIXIAWENTI:

秒速赛车6码计划   1.SHEWANGANJIANDEFENSANGUANXIAMOSHIKENENGCHANSHENG“LEIAN”CAIPANGUIZEBUTONGYI,CONGERYINGXIANGSIFAGONGXINLI。XIANXINGLIFAGUIDINGFUYUMAISHOURENZHUSUODI、BEIGAOZHUSUODI、YUANGAOZHUSUODI、QINQUANXINGWEIDI、PINGTAISUOZAIDIFAYUANJUNKENENGJUYOUDUISHEHULIANWANGANJIANSUSONGDEGUANXIAQUAN,ZHEZHONGJIAOWEIFENSANDEGUANXIAMOSHIBUJINGEIHULIANWANGQIYEHEWANGLUOSHIYONGZHEDAILAIHENDADEKUNHUOYUBUBIAN,ERQIEYEZAOCHENGTONGYIZHUTIQISUDESHEWANGANJIAN,YINWEIGUANXIALIANJIEDIANBUTONGERYOUBUTONGDEHULIANWANGFAYUANHUOZHEQITADIQUFEIHULIANWANGFAYUANGUANXIADESIFAXIANXIANG,YOUCIKENENGCHANSHENG“LEIAN”CAIPANGUIZEBUTONGYIDEWENTI。ZHENGRUQIANWENSUOFENXI,BEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANYUGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANFENBIEGUANXIALEBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIZUOWEIYUANGAODUIBUTONGBEIGAOFENBIETIQIDESHANGBAIQISUSONGANJIAN,RUGUOZHEXIESHEWANGANJIANBUSHIYINWEIBEIJINGQUANJINGSHIJUEWANGLUOKEJIGUFENYOUXIANGONGSIJUNTIQICHESUERJIESHU,ZEHENNANBAOZHENGLIANGGEHULIANWANGFAYUANDUIRUCIZHIDUODE“LEIAN”,ZAIFENBIEJINXINGSHITISHENLIZHIHOUNENGGOUTONGYICAIPANGUIZE。CIWAI,ZHENGSHIYINWEIHULIANWANGFAYUANDUISHEWANGANJIANDEGUANXIASHOUZHIYULIFASUOQUEDINGDEWULILIANJIEDIAN,YECHANSHENGLEHULIANWANGFAYUANDUIDANGSHIRENQISUDESHEWANGANJIANYINMEIYOUGUANXIAQUANERYISONGDAOFEIHULIANWANGFAYUANDEWENTI。RUZAIJIANSUOFENXIDEBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUANRENWEIBEIGAOGUANXIAQUANYIYILIYOUCHENGLI,ERCAIDINGYISONGGUANXIADE9FENCAIDINGZHONG,ZHANXIAOCAIYUYANGHENGDONGWANGLUOGOUWUHETONGJIUFENYIAN,BEIGAOYANGHENGDONGZHUSUODIZAIYUNNANSHENGZHAOTONGSHIZHENXIONGXIAN,YUANGAOZHANXIAOCAIYISHOUHUODIZAIBEIJINGSHIFANGSHANQUGONGCHENDAJIE27DANYUAN1HAO506WEIYOUSUZHIBEIJINGHULIANWANGFAYUAN,BEIGAOTICHUGUANXIAQUANYIYI,“BENANZHONG,ZHANXIAOCAICHENGRENXIANGYANGHENGDONGTIGONGDESHOUHUODIZHIXIXUJIADIZHI,QIEDUIZHENSHISHOUHUORENDENGSHENFENDECHENSHUZIXIANGMAODUN,WUFATIGONGHELIJIESHI。BENYUANRENWEI,RUGUOYISHANGSHUXUJIADIZHIZUOWEIGUANXIALIANJIEDIAN,YOUWEIFANGBIANQUEDINGGUANXIA、BIANLISUSONGDELIFAMUDE,QIESUNHAIDUIFANGDANGSHIRENDEHEFAQUANYI,ZUIZHONGYINGXIANGMINSHISUSONGHUODONGDEZHENGCHANGJINXING。GUDUIZHANXIAOCAIYISHOUHUODIWEIYUBEIJINGSHIXIAQUZUOWEIQUELIBENANGUANXIAQUANYIJUDEZHUZHANG,BENYUANBUYUCAIXIN。BENANZHONG,BEIGAODEZHUSUODIYIRANQUEDING,YINCI,YINGDANGYOUBEIGAOZHUSUODIRENMINFAYUANGUANXIA”。15KEJIAN,SHEWANGANJIANDEFENSANGUANXIAMOSHIBULIYUHULIANWANGFAYUANTONGYIGUANXIASHEWANGANJIAN。

  2.SHEWANGJIAOYIDEKUADIYUXINGYUXIANXINGLIFADEDIYUGUANXIAZHIDUXIANGCHONGTU。HULIANWANGSHANGSHIJIAOYIDEZHONGYAOTEDIANSHICHAOYUEKONGJIANDIYUXING,JIRENHERENKEYIZAIRENHEDIDIANTONGGUOSHOUJIHUOZHEBIJIBENDIANNAODENGYUJIEZHUHULIANWANGPINGTAICONGSHISHANGSHIHUODONGDEZHUTIFASHENGJIAOYI。YIWANGLUOMAIMAIHETONGJIUFENWEILI,DANGSHIRENTONGGUODIANZIYOUJIANDEWANGFUHUOJISHITONGXUNGONGJUJINXINGYAOYUE、CHENGNUO,YISHUZIQIANMINGWANCHENGQIANZHANG,HEYIXINGCHENGYUWANGLUOKONGJIAN,ZAIZHEYIGUOCHENGZHONGGENBENJIUBUCUNZAIXIANSHIKONGJIANZHONGDE “HETONGQIANDINGDI”。RUOHETONGTONGGUOWANGLUOLVXING,LVXINGSHUJUKENENGHUIJIEYOUBUTONGLUJINGJINGGUORUOGANWANGLUOFUWUQI,ZAIWANGLUOKONGJIANZHONGDECHUFADIZHI、DAODADIZHIYEHUIYINDANGSHIRENBUJINGYIDECAOZUOXUANZEERQIANCHAWANBIE,SHENZHIKENENGZAIGUOWAIDEFUWUQISHANGZUIZHONGWANCHENGHETONGDELVXING,GENBENJIUBUCUNZAIXIANXINGFAYIYISHANGDE“HETONGLVXINGDI”。[7]HULIANWANGFAYUANDAJIANDEQUANWANGSHANG、WUZHIHUASUSONGFUWUPINGTAI,DUIYUSUSONGCANYURENERYAN,LIAN、KAITING、TIJIAOZHENGJU、QIANSHOUSUSONGWENSHUWUXUZAIRENLAIRENWANG,BINGQIEDAPOLEKONGJIANDEJUXIANXING,SHIXIANCONGWANGLUOKONGJIANDEKUAGUOJIE、KUAXINGZHENGQUDAOSUSONGKONGJIANDEKUAQUYU,[8]YUHULIANWANGSHANGSHIJIAOYIJUYOUHENGAODEQIHEDU。ERXIANXINGLIFAZAIQUEDINGSHEWANGANJIANDIYUGUANXIASHIRENGRANYI“MAISHOURENZHUSUODI”DENGWULIDIDIANZUOWEI“HETONGLVXINGDI”QUEDINGGUANXIAFAYUANDELIANJIEDIAN,GAIDIDIANKENENGYUTONGGUOXINXIWANGLUOFANGSHIJIAOFUBIAODEDESHEWANGJIAOYIMEIYOURENHELIANXI,ZHEJIUNANMIANLINGRENCHANSHENGDUIGAIWULIDIDIANFAYUANGUANXIASHEWANGANJIANHELIXINGDEZHIYI。YINCI,YAOXIANGSHIXIANHULIANWANGFAYUANDUISHEWANGANJIANZHUANYEHUASHENPANDEZHINENG,RUHEZHENZHENGHUIYINGXIANDAIDIANZISHANGWUDUISIFADEYAOQIU,TONGGUOSIFASHENPANBAOZHANGYUCUJINXIANDAIDIANZISHANGWUDEYOUXULIANGXINGFAZHANJIUCHENGWEIHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANDEYINGRANSHIMING。

秒速赛车6码计划   (ER)“SHEWANGANJIAN”FANWEIYUHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENGBUXIANGPIPEI

  SHEHULIANWANGSUSONGANJIANSHIXINGZHUANYEHUASHENLISHIHULIANWANGFAYUANYINGDANGCHENGDANDESHOUYAOGONGNENG。BEIJING、GUANGZHOUYUHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIHOU,WEILESHIXIANHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANYEHUASHENLIANJIANDEGONGNENG,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANYU2018NIAN9YUE7RIQIKAISHISHIXING《GUANYUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENLIANJIANRUOGANWENTIDEGUIDING》(YIXIAJIANCHENG《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》),GAIGUIDINGDI2TIAOMINGQUELEHULIANWANGFAYUANGUANXIAANJIANDEFANWEI,JIBEIJING、GUANGZHOU、HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANJIZHONGGUANXIASUOZAISHIDEXIAQUNEIYINGDANGYOUJICENGRENMINFAYUANSHOULIDEXIALIEDIYISHENANJIAN:(YI)TONGGUODIANZISHANGWUPINGTAIQIANDINGHUOZHELVXINGWANGLUOGOUWUHETONGERCHANSHENGDEJIUFEN;(ER)QIANDING、LVXINGXINGWEIJUNZAIHULIANWANGSHANGWANCHENGDEWANGLUOFUWUHETONGJIUFEN;(SAN)QIANDING、LVXINGXINGWEIJUNZAIHULIANWANGSHANGWANCHENGDEJINRONGJIEKUANHETONGJIUFEN、XIAOEJIEKUANHETONGJIUFEN;(SI)ZAIHULIANWANGSHANGSHOUCIFABIAOZUOPINDEZHUZUOQUANHUOZHELINJIEQUANQUANSHUJIUFEN;(WU)ZAIHULIANWANGSHANGQINHAIZAIXIANFABIAOHUOZHECHUANBOZUOPINDEZHUZUOQUANHUOZHELINJIEQUANERCHANSHENGDEJIUFEN;(LIU)HULIANWANGYUMINGQUANSHU、QINQUANJIHETONGJIUFEN;(QI)ZAIHULIANWANGSHANGQINHAITARENRENSHENQUAN、CAICHANQUANDENGMINSHIQUANYIERCHANSHENGDEJIUFEN;(BA)TONGGUODIANZISHANGWUPINGTAIGOUMAIDECHANPIN,YINCUNZAICHANPINQUEXIAN,QINHAITARENRENSHEN、CAICHANQUANYIERCHANSHENGDECHANPINZERENJIUFEN;(JIU)JIANCHAJIGUANTIQIDEHULIANWANGGONGYISUSONGANJIAN;(SHI)YINXINGZHENGJIGUANZUOCHUHULIANWANGXINXIFUWUGUANLI、HULIANWANGSHANGPINJIAOYIJIYOUGUANFUWUGUANLIDENGXINGZHENGXINGWEIERCHANSHENGDEXINGZHENGJIUFEN;(SHIYI)SHANGJIRENMINFAYUANZHIDINGGUANXIADEQITAHULIANWANGMINSHI、XINGZHENGANJIAN。KEJIAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANJIZHONGGUANXIADEANJIANKEYIFENWEILIANGLEI:YILEIANJIANSHIYUSUSONGYOUGUANDEANJIANSHISHIHEZHENGJUCAILIAOJUNFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGXIANSHANGDEANJIAN,RUSHANGSHUGUIDINGZHONGDE(ER)、(SAN)、(SI)、(WU)、(LIU)SUOSHEJIDEJIUFENANJIANYIJI(YI)、(QI)SUOSHEJIDEBUFENJIUFENANJIAN;LINGYILEIANJIANSHIYUSUSONGYOUGUANDEANJIANSHISHIHEZHENGJUCAILIAOBUFENFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGXIANSHANG、BUFENFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGXIANXIADEANJIAN,RUSHANGSHUGUIDINGZHONGDE(BA)、(JIU)、(SHI)SUOSHEJIDEJIUFENANJIANYIJI(YI)、(QI)SUOSHEJIDEBUFENJIUFENANJIAN。ZHENGYINWEIMUQIANHULIANWANGFAYUANSUOGUANXIADEANJIANHUANCUNZAIANJIANSHISHIHEZHENGJUCAILIAOBUFENFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGXIANSHANG、BUFENFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGXIANXIADEQINGKUANG,《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI1TIAOGUIDING:HULIANWANGFAYUANCAIQUZAIXIANFANGSHISHENLIANJIAN,ANJIANDESHOULI、SONGDA、DIAOJIE、ZHENGJUJIAOHUAN、TINGQIANZHUNBEI、TINGSHEN、XUANPANDENGSUSONGHUANJIEYIBANYINGDANGZAIXIANSHANGWANCHENG。GENJUDANGSHIRENSHENQINGHUOZHEANJIANSHENLIXUYAO,HULIANWANGFAYUANKEYIJUEDINGZAIXIANXIAWANCHENGBUFENSUSONGHUANJIE。YOUCIKEJIAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANDUI“SHEWANGANJIAN”DESUSONGGUANXIA,ZHISHIKAOLVDAO“SHEWANGANJIAN”DETESHUXING,ZAIZUNXUNMINSHISUSONGFAJIQISIFAJIESHIGUANYUDIYUGUANXIAGUIDINGDEQIANTIXIA,JIANGYUANBENYOUBEIJING、GUANGZHOU、HANGZHOUSHIDEJICENGRENMINFAYUANGUANXIADESHANGSHUANJIANJIZHONGYOUHULIANWANGFAYUANGUANXIA,CONGBENZHISHANGBINGWEIGAIBIANMINSHISUSONGFAJIQISIFAJIESHIYIWULIDIDIANZUOWEILIANJIEDIANQUEDINGDIYUGUANXIADEJIBENLUJING。HUANYANZHI,ZAIBEIJING、GUANGZHOU、HANGZHOUSHIYIWAIDEQITAWEISHEZHIHULIANWANGFAYUANDEDIQU,QIJICENGRENMINFAYUANTONGYANGKEYIGENJUMINSHISUSONGFADIYUGUANXIADEGUIDINGGUANXIA《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAOSUOGUIDINGDESHEHULIANWANGSUSONGANJIAN。LIRU,BIZHETONGGUOAlphaFALVZHINENGJIANSUOXITONG,JINYI“WANGLUOGOUWUHETONG”WEIANYOU、YI“JICENGRENMINFAYUAN”WEIFAYUANCENGJI、YI“SHANGHAISHI”WEIDIYUFANWEI、YI“2019NIAN”WEISHIJIANFANWEI、YI“YISHEN”WEISHENLICHENGXU、YI“PANJUE、CAIDING、DIAOJIESHU”WEIWENSHULEIXING,TONGGUOSHANGSHUGUANJIANCISHEDINGGONGJIANSUOCHUCAIPANWENSHU456FEN,16QIECONGZUOCHUCAIPANWENSHUDEFAYUANLAIKAN,JIBENFUGAILESHANGHAISHIDEQUANBUJICENGRENMINFAYUAN。

  HULIANWANGFAYUANJIEZHUHULIANWANGJISHUPINGTAI,ZAISHENPAN《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAOSUOGUIDINGDESHEHULIANWANGJIUFENANJIANSHI,JIANGCHUANTONGMINSHISUSONGZHONGDEQUANBUSUSONGHUANJIEYOUXIANXIAZHUANRUXIANSHANGJINXING,HUOZHEGENJUANJIANDEQINGKUANGJIANGBUFENSUSONGHUANJIEYOUXIANXIAZHUANRUXIANSHANGJINXING,SHIXINGXIANSHANGYUXIANXIAXIANGJIEHEDESUSONGYUNXINGFANGSHI。RANER,GENJUXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFAJIQISIFAJIESHISUOQUELIDEDIYUGUANXIAZHIDU,WEISHEZHIHULIANWANGFAYUANDEQITADIQUDEJICENGRENMINFAYUAN,ZAISHENLI《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAOSUOGUIDINGDEANJIAN,YIJIGEDIFAYUANZAISHENLICHUANTONGDEFEISHEHULIANWANGMINSHANGSHIJIUFENANJIANSHI,WEILEBIANLIYUDANGSHIRENSUSONG,TIGAOSHENPANXIAOLV,TONGYANGYEYOULIYONGXIANDAIXINXIJISHUJINXINGZAIXIANSHENPANDEXIANSHIXUQIU。YINCI,SUIZHUWOGUOFAYUANXINXIHUAJIANSHEZAIQUANGUOGEDIYIJIGEJIFAYUANDEQUANMIANTUIJIN,ZAIGEZHONGXIANDAIXINXIJISHUGONGSIDECANYUJIJISHUZHICHIXIA,XUDUODIFANGFAYUANDOUTONGGUOJIANLIHULIANWANGSUSONGPINGTAIJINXINGWANGSHANGLIAN、WANGSHANGTIJIAOSUSONGZILIAOYUZHENGJU、WANGSHANGJIAOHUANZHENGJU、WANGSHANGZHIZHENG、WANGSHANGKAITING、WANGSHANGDIAOJIEDENGSUSONGHUODONG,SHIJIANZHONGYEXINGCHENGLEYIXIEFENGGEGEYI、GEJUTESEDEXIANSHANGSUSONGSIFAYANGBEN,RU2017NIAN10YUE30RI,SANYA“ZHIHUIFAYUANDIANZISONGDAPINGTAI”ZHENGSHISHANGXIAN,GAIPINGTAISHISANYASHIZHONGJIRENMINFAYUANYUSANYASHISIFAJUSHENDUHEZUO,XIESHOUTENGXUNGONGSIDAZAODEQUANGUOSHOUGE“ZHIHUIFAYUANDIANZISONGDAPINGTAI”,QUANMIANSHIXIANLESIFAJULVSHIKUBIDUI、WEIXINXIAOCHENGXURENLIANSHIBIE、SUSONGWENSHUTUISONG、XIAOCHENGXUQIANMINGQIANSHOU、SONGDAHUIZHIDENGDUOXIANGGONGNENG。[9]ZAIRU,2018NIAN1YUEZAININGBOLIANGJIFAYUANTUIKAIDENINGBOYIDONGWEIFAYUAN,SHIQUANGUOSHOUPITOURUSHIZHANYINGYONGDEYIDONGDIANZISUSONGPINGTAI,JILIAN、SONGDA、ZHENGJUJIAOHUAN、DIAOJIE、TINGSHEN、ZHIXING、CHAYUEDENGSUSONGLIUCHENGYUYITI。“NINGBOYIDONGWEIFAYUAN”JUYOUKEYIDONG、KUASHIKONGDETEDIAN,RANGANJIANSHENLIYOUXIANXIADEMIANDUIMIANTONGSHITONGBUXIANGYIDONGDUANCUOSHIYIBUZHUANBIAN,SHISUSONGBUZAISHOUSHIKONGHECHANGYUXIANZHI,SUIPIANHUASHIJIANDEYILIYONG,BANANCHANGSUOGENGJIALINGHUO,SONGDASUSONGWENSHUGENGWEIBIANJIE。CIWAI,NINGBOYIDONGWEIFAYUANZHIDINGLEQUANGUOSHOUGEYIDONGDIANZISUSONGGUIZE。[10]2019NIAN3YUE23RI,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANZAIZHEJIANGNINGBOSHIZHAOKAIYIDONGWEIFAYUANSHIDIANTUIJINHUI,KAITONGYIDONGWEIFAYUANQUANGUOZONGRUKOU,BINGFABULE《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANGUANYUZAIBUFENFAYUANTUIJIN“YIDONGWEIFAYUAN”SHIDIANGONGZUODETONGZHI》、《GUANYUTUIJIN“YIDONGWEIFAYUAN”SHIDIANGONGZUODEFANGAN》HE《YIDONGWEIFAYUANBIAOZHUNHUAJIANSHEZHINANHEJISHUGUIFAN》,ZI4YUE1RIQIJIANGYIDONGWEIFAYUANSHIDIANDIYUFANWEITUOZHANZHIBEIJINGSHI、HEBEISHENG、LIAONINGSHENG、JILINSHENG、SHANGHAISHI、ZHEJIANGSHENG、FUJIANSHENG、HENANSHENG、GUANGDONGSHENG、GUANGXIZHUANGZUZIZHIQU、SICHUANSHENG、YUNNANSHENG、QINGHAISHENGXIAQUNEISUOYOUFAYUAN。[11]ZUOWEIYIDONGHULIANSHIDAIDEXINXINGSUSONGMOSHI,YIDONGWEIFAYUANCONGGENBENSHANGTUPOLESUSONGDESHIKONGXIANZHI,DUICHUANTONGDESUSONGZHIDUHELILUNCHANSHENGLEJUDADECHONGJI。CIWAI,YIXIECHUANTONGFAYUANHUANGENJUSHENPANXUYAOSHEZHILEHULIANWANGFATING,RU2018NIAN7YUE11RIFUJIANSHAMENHULIQUFAYUANSHELIHULIANWANGFATING。[12]2018NIAN6YUE22RI,JINGSICHUANSHENGGAOYUANPIFUTONGYI,PIDOUQURENMINFAYUANHULIANWANGFATINGZHENGSHIGUAPAICHENGLI,GAIFATINGJIZHONGGUANXIACHENGDOUSHIXIAQUNEISHEHULIANWANGYISHENMINSHANGSHIANJIAN。KEJIAN,FAYUANDEXINXIHUAJIANSHEYIJIGEDIFAYUANDEJIJITANSUOJINYIBUTUIDONGLEXIANSHANGDIANZISUSONGDEZONGSHENFAZHAN。

  “SHELIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN,SHISIFAZHUDONGSHIYINGHULIANWANGFAZHANDAQUSHIDEYIXIANGZHONGDAZHIDUCHUANGXIN”,[13]ZUOWEISHIYINGXINXIHUASHIDAIBIANGEDEYIXIANGSIFAGAIGECUOSHI,WOGUODANDUSHELILEBEIJING、GUANGZHOUHEHANGZHOUSANGEHULIANWANGFAYUAN,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANWEICIYEDANDUZHIDINGLE《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》,QIMUDESHISHIXIANHULIANWANGFAYUANDEZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENG。LINGRENYIHANDESHI,WULUNSHICONG《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAOSUOGUIDINGYOUHULIANWANGFAYUANJIZHONGGUANXIASHEWANGANJIANDEFANWEILAIKAN,HUANSHICONGWOGUOHULIANWANGFAYUANYIJIWEISHEHULIANWANGFAYUANDIQUDEDIFANGFAYUANJUNKEYIGUANXIA《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAOSUOGUIDINGDESHEWANGANJIANDESIFASHIJIANXIANZHUANGLAIKAN,WOGUOXIANXINGLIFAGUANYU“SHEWANGANJIAN”FANWEIDEGUIDINGWUFATIXIANHULIANWANGFAYUANDEZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENG。

  四、定位回歸:破解互聯網法院審判困境之道

  ZAIHULIANWANGJISHUYUSIFASHENPANXIANGJIEHEDESHIDAIBEIJINGXIA,SUIRANHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHELIJIANGWOGUODEDIANZISUSONGTUIXIANGLEXINDEFAZHANGAODU,DANSHI,YANJUANERSI,HULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANXIANZHUANGYUQISHELIDEYUQISHIFOUXIANGQIHE,HULIANWANGFAYUANSHIFOUCHENGDANQILEFEIHULIANWANGFAYUANSUOWUFACHENGDANDESIFAZHINENG?TONGGUODUIHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIZHIJINDESHENPANSHIJIANYIJIWOGUOGUANYUSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGXIANGGUANGUIDINGDEFENXILAIKAN,DAANSIHUBURONGLEGUAN。YUQITAFAYUANJIEZHUHULIANWANGJISHUJINXINGDESUSONGCHENGXUGAIGEXIANGBI,HULIANWANGFAYUANCHULEJUYOUZAISUOZAICHENGSHIJIZHONGGUANXIA《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAODETESHULEIXINGANJIANDETEDIANZHIWAI,ZAIJINXINGXIANSHANGSUSONGHUOZHEXIANSHANGXIANXIASUSONGXIANGJIEHEFANGMIAN,ZHISHICUNZAIXIANSHANGSUSONGHUANJIEDEDUOSHAOYUCHENGDUYOUSUOCHAYIERYI。WULUNSHILIFAHUANSHISHIJIAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANDUISHEWANGANJIANDESHENLIBINGWUDUTEZHICHU。QITAGUOJIAMEIYOUSHELIDULIDEHULIANWANGFAYUAN,BINGWEIYINCIERYINGXIANGQISUSONGCHENGXUDEDIANZIHUA,RUHANGUO2010NIAN3YUE24RIZHIDINGLEZUOWEIDIANZISUSONGYIBANLIFADE《GUANYUMINSHIDENGSUSONGZHONGLIYONGDIANZIWENSHUDEFALV》,GENJUGAIFA,FAYUANZAISUOYOUSUSONGLINGYUYIWUXINGHUOZHERENYIXINGDISHISHIDIANZISUSONG,BINGQIEHANGUOJIHUSUOYOUFATINGDOUPEIBEILEDIANZISHEBEI。[14]SHANGSHIJI90NIANDAIZAOQIDEMEIGUOMINSHISUSONGSHIYONGDIANZISHUJUYIJINGSIKONGJIANGUAN,DAOLE 90NIANDAIHOUQI,HULIANWANGTEBIESHIDIANZIYOUJIANDESHIYONGSHIDEFAXIANCHENGXUZHONGDIANZICHUCUNXINXIDESHIYONGDADAZENGJIA,BINGCHENGXIANCHUFANTIANFUDIDEBIANHUA,LIANBANGMINSHISUSONGGUIZESUIZHIERXIUDING,CAINADIANZIFAXIANCHENGXU。[15]P33-3590 NIANDAIZHONGQI,YINGGUOWOERFUXUNJUEZAI《JIEJINZHENGYI》DEZHONGQIBAOGAOHEZUIZHONGBAOGAOZHONGTICHULEXUDUOYOUGUANMINSHISUSONGZHONGSHIYONGXINXIJISHUDEJIANYI,YOUQIQIANGDIAOYINJINANJIANGUANLIXITONG(BAOKUOANJIANZHUIZONGXITONG、ANJIANJIHUAXITONG、DIANSHIDIANHUAHUIYI、WENJIANHUOQUXITONG)HEDIANZIANJUANXITONG。1999 NIANDE《YINGGUOMINSHISUSONGFA》GUIDINGLEYIXIEDIANZISUSONGDENEIRONG。[16]P111-112YINCI,RUGUOJIANG“HULIANWANGFAYUAN”DENGTONGYU“ZHIHUIFAYUAN”,ZAIXIANYOUMINSHISUSONGLIFASUOQUELIDEJUTISUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZEKUANGJIANEISHENPANSHEWANGMINSHIANJIAN,JINJINQIANGDIAOQIYOULIYUTIGAOSIFASHENPANXIAOLV、FANGBIANDANGSHIRENJINXINGSUSONGDESIFAGONGNENG,JINERGEIHULIANWANGFAYUANTIESHANGXIANDAI“YUANCHENGSHENPAN”、“XIANSHANGSUSONG”DEJINGLIBIAOQIAN,ZEYOUBEIYUHULIANWANGFAYUANSHELISUOYINGCHENGDANDESHIDAISHIMING。

  JIEJINZHENGYISHISIFADEBENZHISHUXING,YIDALIZHUMINGFAXUEJIAMONUO·KAPEILAIDICENGZHICHU:“YIZHONGZHENZHENGXIANDAIDESIFACAIPANZHIDUDEJIBENTEZHENGZHIYIBIXUSHI,SIFANENGYOUXIAODIWEISUOYOURENJIEJIN,ERBUJINJINSHIZAILILUNSHANGDUIYUSUOYOURENKEYIJIEJIN。”[17]P40HULIANWANGFAYUANMINSHISUSONGTONGYANGWUFAHUIBIZHEYIWENTI。HULIANWANGFAYUANSUSONGGAODUYILAIHULIANWANGXINXIJISHU,WOGUODIYIJIAHULIANWANGFAYUAN-HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANDEWANGSHANGSUSONGPINGTAIJIUSHIYITUOALIBABAGONGSITIGONGDEJISHUZHICHIJIANLIBINGYUNXINGDE,CIHOU,YIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANWEIYANGBENSHELILEBEIJINGYUGUANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUAN,KEYISHUO,ZHESANJIAHULIANWANGFAYUANSHIFAYUANXITONGZHONGJUJIAOXIANDAIXINXITONGXUNJISHUDEDIANFAN,RANER,FAYUANXINXIHUAHUOYUE“ZHIHUIFAYUAN”XINGGOUGUOCHENG,SHIYIZHONG“SHIJIANLILIANG”,DANBINGFEISHICHUNCUIDE“JISHUXINGWENTI”。SHOUSHIYONGZHUYIZHEXUEGUANZHIPEI,SHIWUZHUANJIAJIANGZHUYAOJINGLIQINGZHUYUJIEWEI“WULIGOUCHENG”BILEI,YIZHIYURUANYINGJIANSHEBEIBUDUANTUICHENCHUXIN。[18]ZUOWEIFAYUANXINXIHUAJIANSHEDEDIANXINGDAIBIAO,ZHESANJIAJIEZHUXIANDAIXINXITONGXUNJISHUJIANCHENGDEHULIANWANGFAYUAN,JIUQISHENPANXIANZHUANGERYAN,JINJINSHIXIANLEZAIXUNIDEWANGLUOSHIJIEZAIXIANSUSONGDEBIANJIE、GAOXIAODESHENPANGONGNENG,ZHEYUZUIGAORENMINFAYUANYI“NINGBOYIDONGWEIFAYUAN”WEIYANGBENSHIDIANTUIJINDE“YIDONGWEIFAYUAN”WUBENZHIQUBIE,BINGWEIZHENZHENGTIXIANCHU“HULIANWANGFAYUAN”ZHEYIMINGCHENGSUOYUNHANDE“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANYEXING。

秒速赛车6码计划   ZAIKEGUANSHANG,JISHUZAISIFAZHONGDEYINGYONGTIAOZHANLESUSONGYUANZEYUCHENGXUGUIZE,ZAIDIANZISUSONGFAZHANCHUQI,SHEHUIDUIJISHUXIJIEDEZHONGSHISHENZHICHAOGUOLEFALVGUIZE。DANSUIZHUJISHUYINGYONGDEZENGJIA,JIEJUEDIANZISUSONGZHIDUGOUJIANZHONGDESUSONGFALIWENTIYICHENGWEIDANGWUZHIJI,YINWEISIFAGUOCHENGGURANXUYAOXINXITONGXUNJISHUFUZHU,DANJISHUYAOFUWUYUSUSONGGUOCHENG,FUCONGYUCHENGXUDELIXINGGOUJIAN。[19]HULIANWANGFAYUANSHELIZHIJINSHIJIANSHANGDUAN,YIMIANLINSHENPANDEKUNJING,QIEZAOYUZHUANYEHUASHENPANGONGNENGYOUXIAOFAHUIDELIFAPINGJING。YUPOJIEHULIANWANGFAYUANFAZHANSUOZAOYUDEKUNJING,YINGMINGQUEQIZHENGJIESUOZAI。JIUQIYUANYIN,BINGFEISHIHULIANWANGFAYUANZAISHENPANZHONGSHIYONGMINSHISUSONGZHIDUYUGUIZEBENSHENCHUXIANWENTI,ERSHIXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGZHIDUYUGUIZEWUFASHIYINGHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANXUQIU,HUANYANZHI,QIANQUEYUHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANYEHUASHENPANXIANGPIPEIDEMINSHISUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZESHIZHENGJIESUOZAI,YINCI,TANSUOSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZEBUJINSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANFAZHANDEXUYAO,YESHIZHONGYANGSHENGAIWEIJUEDINGSHELIHULIANWANGFAYUANDEYIDAYAOQIU。JINJINIANLAI,ZHENDUISHEWANGANJIANSHENLIYUMINSHISUSONGJUTIZHIDU、CHENGXUGUIZEZHIJIANDECHONGTU,YIYOUXUEZHECONGDANGSHIRENSHENFENSHIBIEDEJISHUGUIZEYIJIGUANXIA、ZHENGJUYUNYONG、LIAN、SONGDA、SHENLIDENGFANGMIANDUISUSONGCHENGXUJISHUCAOZUOCENGMIANDEGUIZEWANSHANJINXINGLEYOUYITANTAO,[20]YEYOUXUDUODIFANGFAYUANKAIZHANLEJIJISHIJIANTANSUO,DANSIHURENGRANWUFAJIEJUEHULIANWANGFAYUANSHENPANSHIJIANSUOMIANLINDEWENTI,YENANYIHUIYINGHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANYEHUASHENPANDEXIANSHIXUQIU,JIUQIGENYUANZAIYUXIANYOUDETANTAOGENGDUOGUANZHUDESHIXINXIJISHUYUSIFASHENPANXIANGJIEHEBEIJINGXIA,TONGGUOXINXIJISHUDEYUNYONGYOUHUAXIANGYINGDESUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZE,CONGERTIGAOSUSONGCHENGXUDEBIANJIEXINGYUSIFAXIAOLV,RANERQUEHULVELEHULIANWANGFAYUANSUOCHENGDANDE“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENG,JIHULVELEHULIANWANGFAYUANYUJIEZHUXIANDAIXINXIJISHUJINXINGXIANSHANGSUSONGHUOZHEXIANSHANGXIANXIAXIANGJIEHESUSONGDEFEIHULIANWANGFAYUANZHIJIANDEBENZHIQUBIE。HUANYANZHI,DUIHULIANWANGFAYUANDEDINGWEILIJIECHUXIANLEPIANCHA。

  CONGZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN《HULIANWANGFAYUANGUIDING》DI2TIAO“BEIJING、GUANGZHOU、HANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANJIZHONGGUANXIASUOZAISHIDEXIAQUNEIYINGDANGYOUJICENGRENMINFAYUANSHOULIDEXIALIEDIYISHENANJIAN:……”DEBIAOSHULAIKAN,ZUIGAORENMINFAYUANJIANGHULIANWANGFAYUANDINGWEIYUJIZHONGGUANXIASHEWANGTESHULEIXINGANJIANDEKUAXINGZHENGQUHUAFAYUAN。2013NIAN11YUE,DANGDESHIBAJIESANZHONGQUANHUITONGGUODE《ZHONGGONGZHONGYANGGUANYUQUANMIANSHENHUAGAIGERUOGANZHONGDAWENTIDEJUEDING》TICHU:“TANSUOJIANLIYUXINGZHENGQUHUASHIDANGFENLIDESIFAGUANXIAZHIDU,BAOZHENGGUOJIAFALVTONGYIZHENGQUESHISHI。”SHELIKUAXINGZHENGQUHUARENMINFAYUAN,TONGGUOJIZHONGZHIDINGGUANXIA,SHIXIANPUTONGANJIANZAIXINGZHENGQUHUARENMINFAYUANBANLI、TESHUANJIANZAIKUAXINGZHENGQUHUARENMINFAYUANBANLIDESUSONGGEJU。KUAXINGZHENGQUHUAFAYUANDEGUANXIAZHIDUZEYIANJIANFUHEYISHOUDIFANGGANRAO、KUAXINGZHENGQUHUA、ZHONGDADENGBIAOZHUNWEIJICHUGOUJIAN,CONGERSHIXIANSIFAGUANXIAQUYUXINGZHENGQUHUAXIANGFENLI。[21]YOUCIKEJIAN,KUAXINGZHENGQUHUAFAYUANJIZHONGGUANXIATESHUANJIANDEZHUYAOMUDEZAIYUTONGGUOSIFAGUANXIAQUYUXINGZHENGQUHUADESHIDANGFENLI,BAOZHENGANJIANDEGONGZHENGSHENPANYIJIGUOJIAFALVDETONGYIZHENGQUESHISHI,ZHEYUHULIANWANGFAYUANSUOCHENGDANDE“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHINENGSHICUNZAIBENZHIQUBIEDE。ZHONGYANGSHENGAIZUHUIYISHENYITONGGUO《GUANYUSHELIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANDEFANGAN》,HUIYIQIANGDIAODEZHONGDIANZHIYIJIUSHITONGGUOSHELIHANGZHOUHULIANWANGFAYUANTANSUOSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZE,ERYISHIXIANZHUANYEHUASHENPANWEIMUBIAOGOUJIANSHEWANGANJIANSUSONGGUIZELIYINGYISHEWANGANJIANDEBENZHITEZHENGWEIJICHU。

  KEXUEJISHUDEXUNMENGFAZHAN,TEBIESHIJISUANJIDEXUNSUPUJI、WANGLUOTONGXUNJISHUDEGUANGFANYINGYONG,DIZAOLEYIGEYIXINXIHUAWEIHEXINDESHIDAI。ZAIZHEGESHIDAILI,RENYURENZHIJIANDESHANCHUANZUGEBEICHEDIXIAOCHU,ZHENGGESHIJIECHENGLEPINGDE。[22]P42WANGLUOWUDIYUSHIDEMINSHANGSHIFALVGUANXISUOSHEJIDESHISHIJUNFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGSHANGDESHEWANGANJIAN,QIBENZHITEZHENGZAIYUCHAOYUEWULIKONGJIANYUDIYUDETEXING,YOUCICHANSHENGDESHEWANGANJIANMINSHISUSONG,ZAIQUEDINGQIGUANXIAFAYUANSHI,RUGUORENGRANSHIYONGXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFAJIYUCHUANTONGMINSHIANJIANYISUOSHEJISHISHIDEWULILIANJIEDIANWEIJICHUSUOQUEDINGDEGUANXIAZHIDU,BIRANZHIJIEYINGXIANGHULIANWANGFAYUANDUISHEWANGMINSHIJIUFENDEGUANXIAFANWEI,CONGERYANZHONGZHIYUEHULIANWANGFAYUANSUOCHENGDANDE“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANMENHUASHENPANGONGNENGDEYOUXIAOSHIXIAN。CONGFAZHANQUSHIKAN,HULIANWANGFAYUANSHIZHIHUIFAYUANZHUIQIUWANGLUOKONGJIANFAZHIHUADEBENZHIXUYAO,JUYOUZHILILINGYUHESIFAYINGDUIDEZHUANMENXING。YINCI,YUSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANZOUCHUMUQIANDESHENPANKUNJING,POJIEZHIDAOZAIYUYI“WANGSHANGANJIAN”CHAOYUEWULIKONGJIANDIYUDETESHUXINGWEIJICHUHUIGUIHULIANWANGFAYUANYINGYOUDEZHUANYEXING,JIANGHULIANWANGFAYUANDINGWEIYUSHENPANZHUANYEXINGANJIANDEZHUANMENFAYUAN,ERFEISHENPANTESHUANJIANDEKUAXINGZHENGQUHUAFAYUAN。HUANYANZHI,HULIANWANGFAYUANBINGFEICHUANTONGFAYUANDEWANGLUOBANHETIDAIPIN,QISHELIMUDEBUJINSHISHIXIANMINSHISUSONGDEDIANZIHUA、WANGLUOHUA、XINXIHUA、ZHINENGHUA,ERSHIYUCHUANTONGFAYUANBINGLIDEJUYOUDUTEGONGNENGDEZHUANMENFAYUAN。[23]KEJIAN,YIHULIANWANGFAYUANWEIZAITI,CONGSHITIFAYUANZHUANXIANGWANGLUOFAYUAN,GUANJIANZAIYUSHIXIANDIANZILIANLUOHEDIANZIANJUAN。ZAIZHEYIGUOCHENGZHONG,HULIANWANGFAYUANCHENGZAIZHUSUSONGGUIZEDECHUANGXIN,ZHINENGHUA、JISHIXING、XUNIXINGHEWUKONGJIANJUXIANXING,CHONGJIZHUCHUANTONGSUSONGFANGSHIHEGUIZE,[24]ZHEJIUJUEDINGLEHULIANWANGFAYUANSUSONGYINGDANGMINGQUELIANGGEJIBENBIAOZHUN:YISHIHULIANWANGFAYUANGUANXIADEANJIANYINGDANGSHISUOYOUANJIANSHISHIHEZHENGJUCAILIAOJUNFASHENGZAIHULIANWANGSHANGDEANJIAN;ERSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANDEGUANXIAYOUDANGSHIRENXUANZE,BUSHOUXIANSHIKONGJIANZHONGWULIDIDIANDEZHIYUE。YINCI,ZHIYOUHUIGUIHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANMENFAYUANDEDINGWEI,CAINENGSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANSUSONGTUPOXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFASUOQUELIDEDIYUGUANXIAZHIDUDEFANLI,TIAOCHUYIXIANXINGMINSHISUSONGFAZHIDUKUANGJIAYUHULIANWANGFAYUANSUSONGDEPIPEIDUWEIJICHUTANSUOHULIANWANGSUSONGTESHUGUIZEDELUOJIGUAIQUAN,ZHENZHENGTANSUOHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANYEHUASHENPANSUOXUYAODESUSONGZHIDUYUCHENGXUGUIZE。

秒速赛车6码计划   HULIANWANGFAYUANZAIQUANMIANSHENHUASIFATIZHIGAIGEDEBEIJINGXIAKAIPILEYIKUAIQUANXINDELINGYU,ZAIJUJIAOGUOJIAYIJISHEHUIGEJIEQIWANGDETONGSHI,YECHENGDANZHUXIANDAIHULIANWANGSHIDAIYINGYOUDESIFAZEREN。XIWANGTONGGUOJISHIJIANSHIHULIANWANGFAYUANDESHENPANSHIJIANZHUANGKUANG,NENGGOUMINGQUEHULIANWANGFAYUANZHUANMENFAYUANDEDINGWEI,BINGYICIWEIJICHUJINYIBUTANSUOHULIANWANGSUSONGGUIZE,BAOZHANGSHIXIANHULIANWANGFAYUAN“WANGSHANGANJIANWANGSHANGSHENLI”DEZHUANYEHUASHENPANZHIZEYOUSUOQISHI。

  參考文獻
  [1] 中央深改組批準設立杭州互聯網法院[EB/OL].
  [2] CNNIC:2018年第42次中國互聯網絡發展狀況統計報告[EB/OL].
  [3] [德] Peter Gilles:德國民事訴訟程序電子化及其合法化與 “E—民事訴訟法” 之特殊規則[C],張陳果譯,民事程序法研究,第 3 輯,福建:廈門大學出版社,2007.
  [][4 ] 王福華,電子法院:由內部到外部的構建[J],當代法學,2016(5).
  [5] 劉敏,電子訴訟潮流與我國民事訴訟法的應對[J],當代法學,2016(5).
  [6] 于志剛,互聯網法院的歷史意義和時代價值[EB/OL],文章來源:人民法院新聞傳媒總社.
  [7] 于海防,涉網絡合同案件地域管轄法院的確定——從傳統理論與現實規范出發[J],北京理工大學學報(社會科學版),2011(2).
  [8] 鄧恒,從智慧法院的視角理解互聯網法院[N],人民法院報,2017 -08-07(2).
  [9] 全國首個微信電子訴訟文書送達小程序在三亞上線[EB/OL].
  [10] “寧波移動微法院”始于余姚法院一部手機打官司輕松搞定[EB/OL].
  [11] 移動微法院全國總入口開通[EB/OL],http://www.CRNTT.com 2019-03-23 17:56:26.
  [12] 湖里法院互聯網法庭[EB/OL],http://dq.hlcourt.gov.cn/;福建首個互聯網法庭“全在線”訴訟平臺在廈門湖里啟動[EB/OL],2018-07-12.
  [13] 抓好各項改革協同發揮改革整體效應朝著全面深化改革總目標聚焦發力,[N]人民日報,2017-06-27.
  [14] [韓]鄭永煥,韓國電子訴訟現狀及完善方向[J],方麗妍譯,東南司法評論,2018.
  [15] See Miklós Kengyel,Zoltán Nemessányi Editors.Electronic Technology and Civil Procedure—New Paths to Justice from Around the World,Springer.2012 .
  [16] [英]理查德·薩斯坎德,法律人的明天會怎樣———法律職業的未來[M],何廣越譯,北京:北京大學出版社,2015.
  [17] [意]莫諾·卡佩萊蒂等,當事人基本程序保障權與未來的民事訴訟[M],徐昕譯,北京:法律出版社,2000.
  [18] 安晨曦,電子訴訟型塑的中國策略[J],湖北社會科學,2017(8).
  [19] 王福華,電子訴訟構建的法律基礎[J],法學研究,2016(6).
  [20] 張興美,中國民事電子訴訟年度觀察報告(2017)[J],當代法學,2018(6).劉敏,電子訴訟潮流與我國民事訴訟法的應對[J],當代法學,2016(5).陳錦波,論信息技術對傳統訴訟的結構性重塑—從電子訴訟的理念、價值和原則切入[J],法制與社會發展(雙月刊),2018(3).馬登科、唐豪,我國網上立案制度研究[J],廣西社會科學,2018(2).等等。
  [21] 江必新,從跨區劃管轄到跨區劃法院—兼論新型訴訟格局之構建[J],人民司法,2017(31).
  [22] [美]托馬斯·弗里德曼,世界是平的[M],何帆、肖瑩瑩、郝正非譯,湖南:湖南科學技術出版社 2006.
  [23] 肖建國、莊詩岳,論互聯網法院涉網案件地域管轄規則的構建[J],法律適用,2018(3).
  [24] 洪冬英,司法如何面向“互聯網+”與人工智能等技術革新[J],法學,2018(11).