秒速赛车6码计划

法律論文范文欄目為您提供《認罪認罰從寬制度中選擇性不起訴的濫用與規制》范文一篇,希望對您在論文寫作的時候有所幫助
您當前的位置:高質代筆網 > 論文范文 > 法律論文范文 >

認罪認罰從寬制度中選擇性不起訴的濫用與規制

添加時間:2019/10/12

  摘要:秒速赛车6码计划認罪認罰從寬制度包括犯罪嫌疑人、被告人既認罪又認罰的從寬和特殊案件中犯罪嫌疑人的認罪從寬兩種情形。認罪認罰從寬制度中的實體從寬既包括量刑從寬也包括定罪從寬。該制度的推行強化了檢察機關選擇性不起訴的權力,一定程度上改變了我國傳統上以起訴法定主義為主、輕罪案件才適當兼采起訴便宜主義的審查起訴原則,但也加大了濫用風險。檢察機關的選擇性不起訴主要存在六種不當情形:身份優遇型;法不責眾型;穩定大局型;控辯交易型;教訓策略型;徇私枉法型。防范選擇性不起訴的濫行,在法律層面需要廢除“公訴轉自訴”制度,構建準起訴程序和法官事前同意制度,完善法院對檢察機關選擇性不起訴的審查和制約機制;完善認罪認罰從寬制度特別是值班律師制度,構建污點證人作證豁免制度;賦予不起訴一定的實質確定力,防止不起訴后的隨意再訴。

  關鍵詞:秒速赛车6码计划認罪認罰從寬制度; 選擇性不起訴; 準起訴程序; 污點證人作證豁免;

  一、問題的提出

  GONGXINLIBUZUSHIWOGUOJIANFAJIGUANMIANLINDEGONGTONGKUNJING,YESHIZHIYUEXINGSHISUSONGFAZHIJIANSHEDEPINGJING。XUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGWUYISHIJIANCHAJIGUANGONGXINLIBUZUDEZHONGYAOZHIYIN。SUOWEIXUANZEXINGBUQISU,SHIZHIZAIYOUQUESHICHONGFENDEZHENGJUZHENGMINGFANZUISHISHIZHEWEIDUORENHUOZHECUNZAIDUOGEFANZUIXINGWEIDEANJIAN,HUOZHEYIDINGSHIQINEIFASHENGDEJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEDEANJIANZHONG,JIANCHAJIGUANYOUXUANZEDIDUIBUFENFANZUIXIANYIRENHUOZHEFANZUIXINGWEIBUYUQISUDEXINGWEI。

認罪認罰從寬制度中選擇性不起訴的濫用與規制

秒速赛车6码计划   ZAIWOGUOXINGSHISUSONGSHIJIANZHONG,JIANCHAJIGUANJINGUANZAIJIJIZHUISUFANZUIXIANYIRENDEXINGSHIZERENFANGMIANCUNZAIYIXIEJIDAIJIEJUEDEWENTI,DANXIAOJIBUQISUMIANXIANGDEWENTITEBIESHIXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEISHIFANXIANXIANGKENENGGENGWEIYANZHONG。JUMEITIBAODAO,GUANGXIYANGSHUOXIANGUOTUJUYUANJUCHANGSHIBAOCHUNSHOUHUIWOANZHONG,BAOKUOSHIRENYANGSHUOXIANFUXIANCHANG、JIANSHEGUIHUAJUJUCHANGDENGZAINEIDE20DUORENSHOUSHOULEXINGHUIRENDEHUILU,ZUIDUODESHOULE80WAN,DANZUIHOUZHIYOUSHIBAOCHUNYIRENHUOXING。[1]CILEIXUANZEXINGBUQISUXIANXIANGBINGBUXIANJIAN,DUIJIANCHAGONGXINLIDECHONGJIHESUNHAIJIAODA。BIJING,ZAIWOGUODANGXIA,SHEHUIGONGZHONGRENGRANPUBIANHUAIYOUQIANGLIEDESHIZHIZHENGYIXINLI,XINFENGHEZUNCONGYOUZUIBIFAYUANZE,DUIYUJUYOUTONGYANGFANZUIGOUCHENGHELEISIQINGJIEDEFANZUIXIANYIRENTIQIGONGSU,ZHETONGCHANGHUIBEISHIWEILISUODANGRAN(SHUYUFADINGBUQISUQINGXINGDECHUWAI),DANRUOJIANCHAJIGUAN“FANGQI”QISUQIZHONGMOUGE/XIEFANZUIXIANYIRENHUOZHEFANZUIXINGWEI,ZERONGYIBEIHUAIYIWEIFAWAIKAIENHUOZHECUNZAIQITABUZHENGDANGYINSU,JINERKENENGYINFACHENGDUBUTONGDEZHIYI、BUMANNAIZHIPIPAN。

秒速赛车6码计划   YIHANDESHI,DUIYUJIANCHAGONGSUQUAN,WOGUOJIYOUDEYANJIUZHUYAOJUJIAOYUXUANZEXINGQISU,[2]DUIXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEGUANZHUXIANGDUIJIAOSHAO,ERQIESHICHANGBUJIAQUFEN,JIANGHEFAHELIDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUYUCUOWUDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUZAROUZAIYIQIJINXINGTAOLUN,YIZHIZAIMOUZHONGCHENGDUSHANGZHEBILEDUISHIJIANZHONGDE“ZHENWENTI”ZHIJIESHIHEJIEJUE。

  CONGXINGSHISUSONGDELISHIFAZHANHEGUONEIWAISHIJIANLAIKAN,XUANZENAIXIANDAIGONGSUHUODONGDEJINGSUI,JIANCHAGONGSUQUANDEXINGSHIBIRANBANSUIZHUCAILIANGDEWENTI。[3]ZAIWOGUO,JIYUDUISUSONGGUILVDEBAWOHEXINGSHIZHENGCEDEKAOLV,XINGSHISUSONGFAGUANYUZHUODINGBUQISU、FUTIAOJIANBUQISUYIJIDANGSHIRENHEJIEDEGONGSUANJIANSUSONGCHENGXUDEGUIDINGJIUMINGQUEFUYULEJIANCHAJIGUANJIAODADEXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLI,JIDUIYUFANZUIQINGJIEQINGWEI,BUXUYAOPANCHUXINGFADEFANZUIXIANYIREN,NAIZHIKENENGPANCHUYINIANYOUQITUXINGYIXIAXINGFAQIEFUHETEDINGTIAOJIANDEWEICHENGNIANFANZUIXIANYIREN,JIANCHAJIGUANKEYIZHENZHUOJUEDINGBUYUQISU。

秒速赛车6码计划   RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDETUIXINGWUYIJINYIBUQIANGHUALEJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEQUANLI。2016NIAN7YUE22 RI,ZHONGYANGQUANMIANSHENHUAGAIGELINGDAOXIAOZUSHENYITONGGUOLE《GUANYURENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUGAIGESHIDIANFANGAN》。2016NIAN9YUE4RI,《QUANGUORENMINDAIBIAODAHUICHANGWUWEIYUANHUIGUANYUSHOUQUANZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANZAIBUFENDIQUKAIZHANXINGSHIANJIANRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUSHIDIANGONGZUODEJUEDING》SHOUQUANZAIXINGSHISUCAICHENGXUSHIDIANDIQUSHIXINGRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDU,DUIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZIYUANRUSHIGONGSHUZIJIDEZUIXING,DUIZHIKONGDEFANZUISHISHIMEIYOUYIYI,TONGYIRENMINJIANCHAYUANLIANGXINGJIANYIBINGQIANSHUJUJIESHUDEANJIAN,KEYIYIFACONGKUANCHULI。2018NIANXIUZHENGHOUDE《XINGSHISUSONGFA》BUJINZAIDI15TIAOZHUANMENQUELILERENZUIRENFACONGKUANYUANZE,ERQIEZAIZHENCHA、QISU、SHENPANDENGHUANJIEJUNGUIDINGLERENZUIRENFACONGKUANDEXIANGGUANNEIRONG,DALITUIJINRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDESHIJIAN。YOUQISHIXINZENGDEDI182TIAOMINGQUEGUIDING:“FANZUIXIANYIRENZIYUANRUSHIGONGSHUSHEXIANFANZUIDESHISHI,YOUZHONGDALIGONGHUOZHEANJIANSHEJIGUOJIAZHONGDALIYIDE,JINGZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANHEZHUN,GONGANJIGUANKEYICHEXIAOANJIAN,RENMINJIANCHAYUANKEYIZUOCHUBUQISUJUEDING,YEKEYIDUISHEXIANSHUZUIZHONGDEYIXIANGHUOZHEDUOXIANGBUQISU”。JUCI,JIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLIDESHIYONGYIJINGCHAOCHULEQINGZUIFANWEI,KUOZHANDAOZHONGZUIANJIAN,CONGERZAIYIDINGCHENGDUSHANGGAIBIANLEWOGUOCHUANTONGSHANGYIQISUFADINGZHUYIWEIZHU、QINGZUIANJIANCAISHIDANGJIANCAIQISUBIANYIZHUYIDESHENCHAQISUYUANZE,KUODALEQISUBIANYIZHUYIDESHIYONGLINGYU,WEIKUANYANXIANGJIXINGSHIZHENGCEDEGUANCHETIGONGLEGENGWEIGUANGKUODEKONGJIAN。

  JIUCIERYAN,DUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANDESHENCHAQISUHUODONG,DANGQIANJIXUTANTAODEWENTIBUSHIYAOBUYAOJINXINGXUANZEXINGQISU,ERSHIZAIBIRANYAOJINXINGXUANZEXINGQISUDEQIANTIXIAZENYANGXUANZECAIJUYOUZHENGDANGXINGHEKEJIESHOUXING。XIANGYINGDI,BAJIANCHARENYUANCHUYUXUNSIWUBIDEDONGJIZUOCHUDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUJUEDINGYUYIFAHELIZUOCHUDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUJUEDINGHUNHEQILAIJINXINGTAOLUN,WANGWANGJIUQUEFAZHENDUIXING,WUFACHUJIXIANSHIDEZHENGJIE,YENANYIYOUXIAODIHUIYINGANJIANDANGSHIRENHESHEHUIGONGZHONGDEXIANSHIGUANQIE。

  ZONGSHANG,ZAIRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDETUIXINGBEIJINGXIA,JIAQIANGDUIXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEYANJIU,TANJIUQIHELIDEGUIZHILUJING,QUEBAOJIANCHAJIGUANGANYUHESHANYUXINGSHIBUQISUQUANLIDETONGSHI,FANGFANBUQISUQUANLIDELANYONG,JIUXIANDEGEWAIZHONGYAO。

  二、選擇性不起訴的濫行及其實踐樣態

  XUANZEXINGBUQISUSHIFALVFUYUJIANCHAJIGUANDEQUANLI,DANQIXINGSHISHIYOUTIAOJIANDE,BIXUZUNXUNQUANLIFADINGYUANZEHEHELIYUANZE。RUGUOJIANCHAJIGUANGUYICHAOYUEFALVGUIDINGHUOZHEWEIBEIHELIYUANZEJINXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,ZEGOUCHENGQUANLIDELANYONG。YILANYONGXINGTAICHUXIANDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUJIBUTONGYUFADINGBUQISUHUOCUNYIBUQISU,YEYUJIANCHAJIGUANZAIFADINGQISUCAILIANGQUANFANWEINEIHELIZUOCHUDEBUQISUCUNZAIBENZHICHAYI。

  XUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGJUYOURUXIAJIGETEZHENG:QIYI,TASHIJIANCHAJIGUANGUANCHEKUANYANXIANGJIXINGSHIZHENGCEDEBANSHENGWU,XINGSIBUQISUCAILIANGQUANDEZHENGDANGXINGSHI,SHIZEBUQISUQUANLIDESHIJIANYIHUA。QIER,TAYIANJIANYIJUBEITIQIGONGSUDEFADINGTIAOJIANWEIQIANTI。GENJUWOGUO2018NIAN《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DI176TIAODEGUIDING,DUIBUJUBEIFADINGQISUTIAOJIANDEANJIAN,JIANCHAJIGUANYIFAZHINENGZUOCHUBUQISUDEJUEDING。ZHIYOUDUIJUBEIFADINGQISUTIAOJIANDEANJIAN,JIANCHAJIGUANCAIKEGENJUANJIANXINGZHI、FANZUIQINGJIEDEYANZHONGCHENGDU、SHEHUIWEIHAIXINGDAXIAO、SHIFOUSHEJIGUOJIAZHONGDALIYI、FANZUIRENDERENSHENWEIXIANXINGDENGXIANGGUANYINSUYOUXUANZEDIBUYUQISU。QISAN,TACUNZAIYUDUORENFANZUIDEANJIAN,HUOZHEYIDINGSHIQINEIFASHENGDEJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEDEANJIAN。JUTIBAOKUO:(1)GONGTONGFANZUIANJIAN,BAOKUOSHURENGONGFANYIZUI、SHURENGONGFANSHUZUIYIJILIANHUANGONGTONGFANZUIDEANJIAN。(2)DUIHEFANHUOZHETONGYISHIJIANYINFADUOGEFANZUIXINGWEIDEANJIAN。QIANZHERUHUILUFANZUI;HOUZHEZHUYAOZHIQUNTIXINGFANZUIANJIAN。(3)TONGYILEIANJIAN[4],JIYIDINGSHIQINEIFASHENGDEJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEDEANJIAN。CONGLILUNSHANGJIANG,ZAIZHEJILEIANJIANZHONG,CAITUCHUCUNZAIZHUXIANGHUBIJIAOYIJIXUANZESHIFOUQISUDEWENTI。QISI,JIANCHAJIGUANZHUGUANSHANGCUNZAIGUYI,JIMINGZHIXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEICHAOYUELEFALVGUIDINGHUOZHEWEIBEIHELIYUANZEERRENGRANWEIZHI。LIFAFUYUJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLIDEQIANTIJIASHESHI,JIANCHAGUANNENGGOUZUOWEIGONGZHONGLIYIDEZHONGSHIDAILIREN,YIJUZHENGJU、FALVHEZHENGCEKEGUANGONGZHENGDIJUEDINGSHIFOUQISUYIJIRUHEZHUISU,DANSHIJIANZHONGJIANCHAGUANBINGFEIZONGNENGZUODAOKEGUANGONGZHENG,YOUSHIKENENGHUIWEIBEIGONGGONGLIYIXINGSHIXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLI。

秒速赛车6码计划   CONGYIWANGDESUSONGSHIJIANKAN,WOGUOJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGBIAOXIANWEIDUOZHONGBUTONGDEYANGTAI。JIYUQIYUANYOUHETEZHENG,DAZHIKEYIGAIKUOWEIYIXIAJIZHONG:

秒速赛车6码计划   YISHISHENFENYOUYUXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIZAIDUORENGONGTONGFANZUIHUOZHEYIDINGSHIQINEIFASHENGDEJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEDEANJIANZHONG,JIANCHAJIGUANYOUYIHUOWUYIDIBAFANZUIXIANYIRENDEZHIWEIDENGSHENFENXINGYAOSUZUOWEIQISUYUFOUDEZHUYAOKAOLV,QISUNEIXIEZAIZHIWEI、JINGJIHUOZHESHILIDENGFANGMIANJIAORUODEFANZUIXIANYIREN,DANDUICHUYUYOUYUZHUANGTAIDEFANZUIXIANYIRENBUYUQISU。BIRU,TONGYANGSHISHISHILEMINGMUZHANGDANDEDAZAXINGWEI,PUTONGLAOBAIXINGBEIYIXUNXINZISHIZUIZHUISU,1GUANYUANZEYIDANGJIZHENGJIHUOZHEXINGZHENGCHUFALESHI。2YOURU,MOUZHENDANGWEISHUJIZHOUMOU、FUSHUJIDENGMOU、ZHENCHANGLIUMOU、FUSHUJIHUANGMOU、TUDIGUANLIBANGONGSHIZHURENJIANDANGWEIMISHUWANGMOUGONGTONGTANWU20YUWANYUANDEANJIANZHONG,JINGUANMEIGERENDETANWUSHUEJIBENXIANGTONG,DANXIANJIANCHAYUANZHIDUIHUANGMOUHEWANGMOUTIQIGONGSU,DUIFUSHUJIDENGMOU、ZHENCHANGLIUMOUYISIFENGUOYOUZICHANZUIBAOQINGCHEAN,DUIZHENDANGWEISHUJIZHOUMOUZEYISIFENGUOYOUZICHANJIEANBAOQINGBUQISU。[5]

  ERSHIFABUZEZHONGXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIDUIYUTONGYISHIQINEIFASHENGDEDALIANGLEISIFANZUIANJIAN,HUOZHETONGYISHISHIYINFADEDUOQILEISIFANZUIANJIAN,SHOUCHUANTONG“FABUZEZHONG”SIXIANGDEYINGXIANG,JIANCHAJIGUANYOUSHIZHIZEQUQIZHONGSHAOLIANGDEFANZUIXIANYIRENTIQIGONGSU,DUIQITAFANZUIXIANYIRENBUYUQISU。BIRU,ZAIYIXIEHUILUANJIANCHULISHANG,ZIXINGZAIFAWAITIGAOFUBAIANJIANDERUZUIBIAOZHUN;ZAICHABANDIYUXINGDAGUIMOFUBAIANJIANZHONG,TUPOFAJIGUIDING,CHUTAICONGKUANZHENGCE;YOUANBUCHA、BIZHONGJIUQING,HUIBIMOUXIEWEIFAFANZUISHISHI、DUISHEANSHUEDAZHEKOU、YIJIDAIXINGHUOJIANGGECHULI。[6]P129ZHENGRUYOUMEITIZAIDIAOCHAJICHUSHANGSUOZHICHUDE,“YIXIEGUANYUANFUBAIANSHOUDAOCHACHUHOU,WANGWANGHUIBAOLUCHUBUSHAOXIASHUXIANGQISONGLI、XINGHUIDEWENTI。ZHEXIERENZHONG,CHULEGEBIEXINGHUISHUETEBIEJUDADE,HUOZHEQIANCHUQITAJINGJIWENTI(RUTANWU、SHOUHUIDENG)DERENWAI,DADUOSHUDOUMEIYOUZHUIJIUXINGSHIZEREN,YOUDESHENZHILIANJILVZERENDOUMEIZHUIJIU。”[7]ZHEZHONGXIANXIANGJIYICHENGWEIZHONGSUOZHOUZHIDE“QIANGUIZE”。[8]

秒速赛车6码计划   SANSHIWENDINGDAJUXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIZAIYIXIEZHIWUFANZUI“WOAN”DECHACHUSHIJIANZHONG,CHUYU“FANGFANJICENGZHENGQUANYUNZUOTANHUAN”HUOZHE“WENDINGDIFANGJINGJIHESHEHUIZHIXU”DENGFANGMIANDEKAOLV,JIANCHAJIGUANYOUSHIHUIDUIMOUXIEFANZUIRENDEQUANBUHUOZHEBUFENFANZUIXINGWEIXUANZEXINGDIBUYUQISU。BIRU,GUANGDONGLUOYINGUOSHOUHUIAN,CHIXUSHIJIANJIAOCHANG,SHEJIDAOTING、CHUJIGANBU240YUREN,DANKAOLVDAOJICENGZHENGQUANDEZHENGCHANGYUNZHUAN,QIZHONGDE160YUMINGGUANYUANMEIYOUBEIQISU。[9]

秒速赛车6码计划   SISHIKONGBIANJIAOYIXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIWEILESHIXIANDUIZHONGDIANFANZUI、ZHONGDIANFANZUIXIANYIRENDEDAJIHECHULI,JIANCHAJIGUANZAIQUEFAFALVGUIDINGHUOZHEMINGQUESHOUQUANDEQINGKUANGXIA,YUTEDINGFANZUIXIANYIRENHUOQILVSHIJINXINGXIESHANG,YIBUQISUGAIFANZUIXIANYIRENDEBUFENHUOZHEQUANBUFANZUISHISHILAIHUANQUQIZHUDONGRENZUIHUOZHEBANGZHUSIFAJIGUANZHIZHENGTAREN。BIRU,ZAIZHUYAOYIKAOXINGHUIRENHESHOUHUIRENDEGONGCILAIZHENGMINGFANZUIDEHUILUANJIANBANLIGUOCHENGZHONG,WEIZHUIJIUZUOWEIZHONGDIANCHACHUDUIXIANGDESHOUHUIRENDEXINGSHIZEREN,JIANCHAJIGUANYOUSHIHUICHUTAIYIBANXINGDEZHENGCEHUOZHEZAIJUTIANJIANZHONGYUXINGHUIRENXIESHANG,MINGQUEBIAOSHIZHIYAOXINGHUIRENTONGYIZUOWEI“WUDIANZHENGREN”ZUOZHENGZHIKONGSHOUHUIRENDEFANZUIXINGWEI,JIUKEYIWANGKAIYIMIAN,DUIQIBUYUQISUHUOZHEJIANSHAOZHIKONG。

  WUSHIJIAOXUNCELVEXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIZAIDUORENGONGTONGFANZUIDEANJIAN,HUOZHEYIDINGSHIQINEIFASHENGDEJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEDEANJIANZHONG,ZUOWEIYIZHONGJIAOXUNHUOBAOFUCELVE,JIANCHAJIGUANDUISUOWEIDE“BUPEIHE”BANANHUOZHEYINXINGSHISUSONGQUANLIDENGXINGWEIGEIBANANJIGUANDAILAIMAFANHUOZHEFENGXIANDEFANZUIXIANYIRENTIQIGONGSU,DUIQITAFANZUIXIANYIRENZEENHUIXINGDIBUYUQISU。BIRU,BEIMEITICHENGWEIXINWENJIE“LIZHUANG”DEQICHONGHUAIANZHONG,FAYUANXIANSHIYIQIAOZHALESUOZUIPANCHUQIYOUQITUXINGSINIAN,HOUYINQI“YUYUFANGCHANGQIDUIKANG,BINGQIEHUANJIANGJIANYUZHONGDEQINGXINGXIECHENGCAILIAOLIUCHUANDAOWANGSHANG”,JIANCHAJIGUANYOUYI“LOUZUI”WEIYOUZAICIQISU。BUGUO,DUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANZHUIJIAZHIKONGDEQIAOZHALESUOFANZUI,BIANHULVSHIRENWEISHIGONGTONGFANZUIXINGWEI,“TONGSHICANYUGUOZHESANQISHIJIANDEHUANYOULINGWAILIANGMINGJIZHE,DANTAMENDOUMEIYOUBEI‘LOUZUIZHUISU’,ZHEXIANRANSHIYIZHONGXUANZEXINGZHIFA”。[10]HUANYANZHI,DUIYUGONGTONGCANYUZHESANQISHIJIANDANBIJIAOPEIHESIFAJIGUANBANANDELINGWAILIANGMINGJIZHE,JIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGDIFANGQILEQISU。

  LIUSHIXUNSIWANGFAXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIZAIDUORENGONGTONGFANZUIDEANJIANZHONG,HUOZHEYIDINGSHIQINEIFASHENGDEJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEDEANJIANZHONG,JIANCHARENYUANCHUYURENQINGGUANZHAO、QINQINGBANGZHU、LIYIYOUHUO、QUANLIGANYUDENGYINSU,DUIMINGZHISHIYIYUTIQIGONGSUDEFANZUIXIANYIRENBUDANGDIFANGZONGHUOZHEQINGZONG,XUANZEXINGDIBUYUZHUISUQIQUANBUHUOZHEBUFENFANZUISHISHIDEXINGWEI。BIJIAODIANXINGDETIXIANSHIGONGTONGFANZUIANJIANZHONG“GONGNENGYIHUA”DE“LINGANCHULI”。3YOUYUQUEFAFALVMINGQUEHEYANGEDEGUIFAN,SHENCHAQISUSHIJIANZHONG,“LINGANCHULI”ZUIHOUDEJIEGUOCHANGCHANGLUNWEI“LINGANBULI”,FANZUIXIANYIRENBEIXUANZEXINGDIBUYUQISU。BIRU,ZAILIANZHUOZHAODIXIAQIANZHUANGXIQIANANDEPANJUESHUZHONG,LIANZHUOZHAOZUOWEIQIANZHUANGDEZHUYAOCHUZIREN,BEIBIAOMINGJIANG“LINGANCHULI”,DANSHIJIQINGKUANGQUESHI:ZHENGSHAODONGCHUMIANGANSHE,JINGSHIRENGUANGDONGSHENGZHENGFAWEISHUJIDECHENSHAOJIPISHI,JIANGMENSHISIFABUMENZUIZHONGFANGQILEDUILIANZHUOZHAODESHENCHAHEQISU。[11]

  ZAISHANGSHULIULEIQINGXINGZHONG,DIYILEIZHUYAOSHIYOUYUJIANCHARENYUANDEZHIYESUYANGBUZUDAOZHIDE;DIER、SANLEIBIAOXIANCHUNONGHOUDEZHENGZHIXINGSECAI;DISILEIZHESHECHUJIANCHAZHIFADEGONGLIXING,SHIJIANCHAJIGUANZAIFAWUMINGWENGUIDINGQINGKUANGXIAXUNQIUZHUISULIYIZUIDAHUADETIXIAN;DIWU、LIULEIQINGXINGXIADEXUANZEXINGBUQISUZESHIZHISHANGLUNWEIJIANCHAJIGUANHUOJIANCHARENYUANMOUQU“YIJIZHISI”DEGONGJU。DANGRAN,ZHEXIEZHISHIJIYURENSHIHEYANJIUDEFANGBIANCHOUXIANGCHULAIDE“LIXIANGLEIXING”,TANGRUOJUTIDAOGEANZHONG,ZEHUIFAXIANXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLILANYONGDEQINGXINGYOUSHIKENENGBIJIAOFUZA,TONGSHIJIANJULIANGZHONGHUOZHELIANGZHONGYISHANGDETEZHENG。

  三、選擇性不起訴的濫行之危害

  XUANZEXINGBUQISUZHIDUDESHELI,ZHIZAIGENGHAODIGUANCHEKUANYANXIANGJIDEXINGSHIZHENGCE,FAHUIXINGSHISIFADEJIAOYUGANHUAGONGNENG,FENHUAWAJIEGONGTONGFANZUIREN,HELIPEIZHISIFAZIYUAN,BAOZHANGFALVDESHISHIYUSHIJUJIN,CUJINSHEHUIGONGGONGLIYI、FANZUIXIANYIRENLIYIYUBEIHAIRENLIYIDEJUNHENGBAOHU,DANSHIJIANZHONGCHUXIANDELANXINGXIANXIANGWUYIHUIFANGAIZHEXIEYUQIMUBIAODESHIXIAN,BINGYINFAHENDUOWENTI,BIHAISHENDA。

  QIYI,WEIBEILEFALVMIANQIANYILVPINGDENGDEYUANZE。WOGUO《XIANFA》DI33TIAOGUIDING:“ZHONGHUARENMINGONGHEGUOGONGMINZAIFALVMIANQIANYILVPINGDENG”。《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DI6TIAOJINYIBUGUIDING:“DUIYUYIQIEGONGMIN,ZAISHIYONGFALVSHANGYILVPINGDENG,ZAIFALVMIANQIAN,BUYUNXUYOURENHETEQUAN”。YOUCIQUELILEFALVMIANQIANYILVPINGDENGYUANZE,HUOZHESHUO,FUYULEGONGMINYAOQIUFALVPINGDENGDUIDAIHEBAOHUDEQUANLI。PINGDENGQUANYUANYUZIRANFALINIANZHIGONGPINGYUZHENGYI,YESHIRENXINZUIYIGANSHOUDEJIAZHIGAINIAN。PINGDENGQUANYAOQIUTONGDENGQINGKUANGTONGDENGDUIDAI,BUTONGSHIWUBUKETONGYANGDUIDAIJIYINGCHABIEDUIDAI。[12]P681HUANYANZHI,YOUYUYAOQIUSUOYOURENDOUYAOCHENGSHOUTONGYANGDEFUDANHUOXIANGYOUTONGYANGDELIYI,ZHEJISHIBUKEDEDE,SHENZHIYESHIBUKEYUDE,[13]P219YINERDUIFALVMIANQIANYILVPINGDENGYUANZEDELIJIEJIUBUNENGCHOULISHIZHIPINGDENGDENEIRONG。BUGUO,SUOYOUDEQUBIEDUIDAIDOUBIXUJUYOUZHENGDANGDELIYOU ,GOUCHENGHELIDECHABIEDUIDAI,FOUZEJIUWEIFANLEPINGDENGYUANZE。DUIYURUHEPANDUANSHIFOUHELIDECHABIEDUIDAI,YOUXUEZHEZHICHU,ZAIFALVSHANGDEYISHEDINGCHABIEDUIDAIDESHIXIANG,QIHESHISHIDE、SHIZHIYIYISHANGDECHAYIZHIGUANXI,ZHIYAOZAISHEHUITONGCHANGGUANNIANKANLAISHIHELIDE,ZHEZHONGCHABIEDUIDAIJIUKERENWEIMEIYOUWEIFANPINGDENG。[14]P100

秒速赛车6码计划   ZUOWEIFALVJIANDUJIGUANHEGONGGONGLIYIDESHOUHUZHE,JIANCHAJIGUANZAISHISHIXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEISHIYINGDANGZUNXUNFALVMIANQIANYILVPINGDENGYUANZE,YIQUEBAOJUYOUXIANGTONGFANZUIGOUCHENG、XIANGSIFANZUIQINGJIEHELIANGXINGQINGJIEDEFANZUIXIANYIRENSHOUDAOLEISIDECHENGFAHUOZHECHUYU。QIANSHUJIYUCHABIEQISHI、JIAOXUNBAOFU、FABUZEZHONG、WENDINGDAJU、XUNSIWANGFADENGYINSUZUOCHUDEXUANZEXINGBUQISU,XIANRANBUSHUYU“ZAISHEHUITONGCHANGGUANNIANKANLAISHIHELIDE”CHABIEDUIDAI,YINERWEIBEILEFALVMIANQIANYILVPINGDENGYUANZE。QIZAISHIJIANZHONGRONGYIDAOZHI“HUAQIANMAIZUI”XIANXIANG,SHIDEWUQIANWUSHIWUQUANDEFANZUIXIANYIRENNANYIXIANGSHOUDAOPINGDENGSHIYONGXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEQUANLI,ZAIGENBENSHANGYINGXIANG“NULIRANGRENMINQUNZHONGZAIMEIYIGESIFAANJIANZHONGGANSHOUDAOGONGPINGZHENGYI”DESIFAMUBIAOZHISHIXIAN。

  QIER,ZUAILEXINGFAYUFANGMUDEDESHIXIAN。JIANCHAJIGUANTONGGUOXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLIDEHELIYUNYONG,DUINEIXIEFANZUIQINGJIEQINGWEIHUOZHERENSHENWEIXIANXING/ZAIFANKENENGXINGBUDADEFANZUIXIANYIRENCAIQUFEIJIANJINCHUYUCUOSHI,SHIQIDEYIJISHIDICONGXINGSHIZHUISUZHUANGTAIZHONGJIETUOCHULAI,YOUCIKEYIBIMIANFANZUIXIANYIRENBEITOURUJIANGUANCHANGSUOYIHOURONGYIFASHENGDE“JIAOCHAGANRAN”FENGXIAN,GENGHAODISHIXIANTEBIEYUFANGDEMUDE。BUGUO,RUGUOJIANCHAJIGUANLANXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISU,JIANGYIFABENYINGSHOUDAOXINGSHIZHUISUHECHENGFADEFANZUIXIANYIRENYUYIWUZUICHULI,ZEKENENGHUIBUDANGDIQIANGHUAFANZUIXIANYIRENFANZUIWEIBIHUISHOUDAOXINGSHICHENGZHIDEJIAOXINGXINLI4YIJIDUIYUFALVHEGUIZEDEMIESHIXINLI,BULIYUDUIFANZUIZHIRENDETESHUYUFANG。BUJINRUCI,YOUYUXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEQUANLILANYONGCHONGJILESIFAPINGDENGYUANZEHEZUIZEXINGXIANGSHIYINGYUANZE,XIAOJIANLESIFADEKEYUQIXING,YINERYEBULIYU“JIANLIHEZENGQIANGSHIMINDUIFALVDEWENDINGYIJIBAOHUFALVZHIXUBUSHOUFANZUIQINFANDEXINREN”[15],SHENZHIKENENGYOUFAQIANZAIDEFANZUIXINGWEI,DAOZHIXINGFADEYIBANYUFANGMUDEYENANYIYOUXIAOSHIXIAN。5

秒速赛车6码计划   QISAN,SUNHAILEBEIHAIRENDEHEFAQUANYI。ZAIXIANSHISHENGHUOZHONG,ZHUIJIUFANZUIRENDEXINGSHIZERENBINGHUOQUHELIDEWUZHIPEICHANG,SHIFANZUIBEIHAIRENDEJIBENSUQIU。DANZAIJIANCHAJIGUANGUYIWEIBEIQISUTIAOJIANHUOZHEHELIYUANZEXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEANJIANZHONG,TANGRUOCUNZAIFANZUIBEIHAIREN,ZEBEIHAIRENDEHEFAQUANYIWUYIMEIYOUDEDAOYINGYOUDEBAOZHANG。XUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXING,SHIDEBUFENFANZUIXIANYIRENHUOZHEFANZUIXINGWEIBUZAIJINRUSHENPANCHENGXUHEZHIXINGCHENGXU,BEIHAIRENTONGCHANGQIJIDE“YOUZUIBIFA”MUBIAOYEJIUWUFASHIXIAN,BAOFUXINLIDEBUDAOCHONGFENMANZU,JINGSHENSUNHAIDEBUDAOYOUXIAOXIUFU。CIWAI,ZAIJIAHAIRENYUBEIHAIRENNANYIDACHENGPEICHANGXIEYIDEXINGSHIANJIANZHONG,YINJIAHAIRENMEIYOUBEITIQIGONGSU,BEIHAIRENDECAICHANSUNSHIJIUZHINENGTONGGUOLINGXINGTIQIMINSHISUSONGQIUCHANG,ZHEBUJINHUIJIADABEIHAIRENDESONGLEI,ERQIESUSONGJIEGUOJUYOUJIAODADEBUQUEDINGXING。

秒速赛车6码计划   QISI,JIAJULESIFAFUBAIXIANXIANG。ZAIQIANSHUXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGXINGTAIZHONG,QIEBUSHUOXUNSIWANGFAXINGHEJIAOXUNCELVEXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISUBENLAIJIUSHI“YIQUANMOUSI”DEXINGWEI,JIBIANSHIQITAXINGSHIDELANYONGXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLIDEXINGWEI,YEYOUYUTUPOLEFALVJIEXIANHUOZHEWEIFANLEHELIYUANZEERBUDANGDIKUOZHANGLEJIANCHAJIGUANDEQISUCAILIANGKONGJIAN。TONGSHI,YOUYUWOGUOJIANCHARENYUANDEZHENGTISUZHIHUANYOUDAITIGAO,SHEHUIRENGRANJUYOUJIAOQIANGDEGUANXISHEHUIHERENQINGSHEHUISECAI,SUSONGDEWAIBUHUANJINGYEBULIXIANG,YINERJIUZENGJIALEZUOWEIGONGGONGLIYIDAILIRENDEJIANCHARENYUANFUBAIDEFENGXIANHEKENENG。6

  QIWU,XIAOJIEFALVDEGONGZHONGRENTONG。FALVDEGONGZHONGRENTONGSHIFAZHIGUOJIAJIANSHEDEZHONGYAOZHICHENG。CONGXINGFAJIAODUKAN,FALVDEGONGZHONGRENTONG“BAOKUODUI‘SHENGHUOLIYIDEZHONGYAOXING’HE‘GUIFANYOUXIAOXING’DERENTONGLIANGGEFANGMIAN,QIZUIZHONGBIAOXIANWEIJIEJUHELI、DUIXINGWEIGUOCHENGDETUODANGPINGJIALIANGDIANSHANG。”[16]ZAIQIANGDIAOYOUZUIBISU、ZHUZHONGSHIZHIZHENSHIHEBAOYINGZHENGYIDEWOGUOZHULIUSUSONGWENHUAZHONG,JIANCHAJIGUANWULUNSHIZAIBUXIANGYOUQISUCAILIANGQUANQIEANJIANMINGXIANYINGDANGQISUDEQINGKUANGXIABUYUQISU,HUANSHIZAIJINGUANCHUYUFALVGUIDINGDEQISUCAILIANGFANWEINEIDANANZHAOQISUBIANYIZHUYIDEJINGSHEN“YISUERBUSU”,JUNBEILILEGONGZHONGDEPUBIANXINNIAN,SUNHAILEGONGZHONGDEFALVYUQI,NANYI“QUEBAOGUOMINDUIXINGFADAJIYOUXIAOXING、BIAOZHUNXINGDEXINLAI”,JINERHUIDUIFALVDEGONGZHONGRENTONGCHANSHENGHENDADEXIAOJIXINGYINGXIANG,JIAJUMINZHONGDUISIFADEBUXINRENGAN,QIANGHUA“XINFANGBUXINFA”DESHEHUIXINLI。ZHENGSHIZAIZHEZHONGYIYISHANG,BIZHERENTONGYOUXUEZHEDEXIASHUPANDUAN:ZAIJIANCHAGUANDEZHIQUANZHONG,YOUQIYIBUZHUISUFANZUIZHIJUEDING,RUBUZHENCHA、BUQISUDENG,ZUIJUDONGYAODULIXINGSHISIFADEXIAOLI。[17]P167CIWAI,RUQIANSUOSHU,WOGUOJIANCHAJIGUANDULIXINGSHIJIANCHAQUANDEBAOZHANGJIZHISHANGWEIWANQUANQUELI,JIANCHARENYUANDEZHIYELUNLISUYANGZHENGTIERYANHUANBUGAO,YINERXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGNANMIANHUIYINFASHEHUIGONGZHONGDUIJIANCHAQUANLIYUNXINGGUOCHENGZHONGFUBAISHENTOUDELIANXIANG,JINERHUAIYIJUTIANJIANZHONGFALVSHIYONGDEGONGZHENGXING,ZHEYEHUIXUERUOFALVDEGONGZHONGRENTONG。7ERQUEFAGONGZHONGRENTONGDEFALVZIRANSHIQULEYUNXINGDESHEHUIJICHU,QUANWEIXINGGENGSHIWUCONGTANQI,JIBIANQIANGZHISHISHI,YEHENNANQUDELIANGHAODEXIAOGUO。

  四、認罪認罰從寬制度的學理辨析

秒速赛车6码计划   WEIGENGHAODIGUANCHEKUANYANXIANGJIDEXINGSHIZHENGCE,TIGAODAJIFANZUIDECHENGXIAO,2018NIANXIUZHENGHOUDEXIN《XINGSHISUSONGFA》QUELILERENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDU。GENJUDI15TIAODEGUIDING,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDU,SHIZHIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZIYUANRUSHIGONGSHUZIJIDEZUIXING,CHENGRENZHIKONGDEFANZUISHISHI,YUANYIJIESHOUCHUFADE,KEYIYIFACONGKUANCHULI。RUOYAOWANZHENGLIJIEHEZHUNQUEBAWORENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDU,HUANBIXUJIEHEXINGSHISUSONGFADI182TIAODEXINZENGGUIDINGJI“FANZUIXIANYIRENZIYUANRUSHIGONGSHUSHEXIANFANZUIDESHISHI,YOUZHONGDALIGONGHUOZHEANJIANSHEJIGUOJIAZHONGDALIYIDE,JINGZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANHEZHUN,GONGANJIGUANKEYICHEXIAOANJIAN,RENMINJIANCHAYUANKEYIZUOCHUBUQISUJUEDING,YEKEYIDUISHEXIANSHUZUIZHONGDEYIXIANGHUOZHEDUOXIANGBUQISU”。CONGTIXIJIESHIDEJIAODUJIANG,GAITIAONEIRONGXIANRANYESHIRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDEYOUJIZUCHENGBUFEN,HUOZHESHUO,GAITIAOMINGQUEGUIDINGLERENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDEYIZHONGTESHUQINGXING:FANZUIXIANYIRENZAITESHUANJIANZHONGDERENZUICONGKUAN。

  JUCI,CONGLEIXINGSHANGKAN,WOGUOXINGSHISUSONGFASUOQUELIDERENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUYINGDANGQUFENWEILIANGZHONGQINGKUANG:YISHIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENJIRENZUIYOURENFADECONGKUAN,CIWEIDIANXINGYANGTAI,YIBANCHUXIANZAISHENCHAQISUJIEDUANHUOZHESHENPANJIEDUAN;ERSHITESHUANJIANZHONGFANZUIXIANYIRENDERENZUICONGKUAN,CIWEITESHUQINGXING,YIBANCHUXIANZAIZHENCHAJIEDUANHUOSHENCHAQISUJIEDUAN。YINCI,BIZHERENWEI,BUSHAOXUEZHEDELUNZHUZHONGJIANGRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUXIANDINGZAIQIANYIZHONGQINGXINGXIAJIAYIYANJIUSHIZHIDETAOLUNDE,ZUIZHUYAODESHIQIWEINENGQUANMIAN、ZHUNQUEDIBAWOXINGSHISUSONGFADELIFAYIZHI。

  QICI,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUZHONGDE“CONGKUAN”JISHIZHISHITICONGKUAN,YEBAOKUOCHENGXUCONGKUAN。SHITICONGKUANYOUTIXIANWEIDINGZUICONGKUAN8HELIANGXINGCONGKUANLIANGZHONGQINGKUANG,ERBUJINJINSHIZHILIANGXINGCONGKUAN;CHENGXUCONGKUANZESHIZHICHENGXUSHANGCONGKUANDUIDAI,JINLIANGBUDUIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENDEQUANYIZAOCHENGJIAODADEGANRAOHEBULIYINGXIANG,JUTIYOUBIAOXIANZAILIANGGEFANGMIAN:ZAISUSONGCHENGXUJINXINGZHONG,JINKENENGDIDUIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENCAIQUJIAOWEIQINGHUANDEFEIJIYACUOSHIHEJIAOWEIBIANJIEDESUSONGCHENGXU(SUCAICHENGXUHUOJIANYICHENGXU);ZAICHENGXUZHONGJIEFANGMIAN,RUGUOANJIANFUHEFADINGTIAOJIAN,ZEGONGANJIGUAN、JIANCHAJIGUANKEYICAILIANGZUOCHUCHEXIAOANJIANHUOZHEBUQISUDECHENGXUZHONGJIECHUFEN。

  ZAICI,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUZAIXINGSHISUSONGFAZHONGDEYIQUELI,JINGUANYUWOGUOXINGSHIFAXUEJIEDUONIANLAIDEXIANGGUANYANJIUHEYIXIEXUEZHEDEJIJICHANGDAOYOUYIDINGDEGUANLIANXING,DANGENGDACHENGDUSHANGSHIGONGJIANFAJIGUANXUQIUQUDONGHESHIJIANTANSUODECHANWU。ZI2002NIANHEILONGJIANGSHENGMUDANJIANGTIELUYUNSHUFAYUANSHENLIDEBIANSUJIAOYIDIYIANYILAI,LILUNSHANGWEIRAOKONGBIANXIESHANGZHIDUDEZHENGLUNYIZHIMEIYOUTINGZHI,ERQIEZAIYIXIESHIJIANJIEDIANSHANGSHIERHUIFASHENGJILIEDECHONGTU。SHIJIANZHONG,JINGUANZUIGAOSIFAJIGUANJIAOTINGLEBIANSUJIAOYIDETANSUO,DANSHIMIANDUISHEHUIGONGZHONGDUIYOUZUIBISU、YOUZUIBIFADEQIANGLIEZHUIQIUYUXINGSHIANJIANCHANGCHANGZHENGJUXIQUEYINERSIFAJIGUANNANYIWANCHENGZHENGMINGZERENZHIJIANDEFANCHA,YIJIXINGSHIANJIANDUOFANANPOYUSIFAZIYUANJINZHANGZHIJIANDEYALIDENGXIANSHIKUNJING,GONGANSIFAJIGUANRENGRANZAIBUTONGCHENGDUDIJINXINGZHUZHENBIANXIESHANG、SUBIANXIESHANGNAIZHISHENBIANXIESHANGDEHUODONG,ZHISHIJIANGQI“GAITOUHUANMIAN”YINYUTAIMIANZHIXIAERYI。YEZHENGSHIZAIXINGSHIBANANJIGUANDEXIANSHIXUQIUTUIDONGXIA,XIANSHIJINGZHONGYANGQUANMIANSHENHUAGAIGELINGDAOXIAOZUSHENYITONGGUO,ERHOUYOUQUANGUORENMINDAIBIAODAHUICHANGWUWEIYUANHUISHOUQUANZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANZAIBUFENDIQUKAIZHANLEXINGSHIANJIANRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUSHIDIANGONGZUO,BINGZAIDUISHIDIANQINGKUANGJINXINGZONGJIEHEWANSHANDEJICHUSHANG,JIANGRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUQUELIZAI2018NIANXIUZHENGHOUDEXIN《XINGSHISUSONGFA》ZHONG。

  YOUCI,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUSHIXINGSHISUSONGFAQUELIDE、JUYOUTEDINGTIAOJIANHENEIRONGGOUCHENGDESUSONGZHIDU,BUNENGDENGTONGYUXINGFAZHONGZAOYIYOUZHIDEZISHOU、TANBAIDENGCONGKUANZHIDU。JUTIERYAN,GOUCHENGXINGFAZHONGDEZISHOU,XUYAOJUBEIFANZUIRENZIDONGTOUAN、RUSHIGONGSHUZIJIDEZUIXINGQIEZIYUANJIESHOUSHENPANDENGTIAOJIAN,[18]P271-274TONGSHIZISHOUQINGJIEDEYINGXIANGZHIJIYULIANGXING,BUCHUJIDINGZUI;RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDESHIYONGZEBUYAOQIUFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZIDONGTOUAN,FANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZHIYAOCHENGRENZHIKONGDEFANZUISHISHIJIKE,YINERBIAOMIANSHANGSIHUBIZISHOUDETIAOJIANKUANSONG,DANSHIZHISHANGBUWANQUANRUCI,YINWEIDIANXINGDERENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUYAOQIUFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZAIRENZUIZHIWAI,HUANYAORENFA(TONGYIJIANCHAJIGUANTICHUDELIANGXINGJIANYI),ERQIEZAIFAYUANNISHIYONGSUCAICHENGXUSHENLIDERENZUIRENFAANJIANZHONG,BEIGAORENHUANYAO“RENCHENGXU”(TONGYISHIYONGSUCAICHENGXU),ERZHEXIEXIANRANSHIZISHOUZHIDUSUOBUYAOQIUDE。CIWAI,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUYIBUNENGDENGTONGYUTANBAIZHIDU。ZAIXUEJIEHESHIWUJIE,YOUYIZHONGZHUDAOXINGDEGUANDIANRENWEI,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUSHI“TANBAICONGKUAN”ZHENGCEDEFADINGHUA。BIZHERENWEI,ZHEYIPANDUANBINGBUSHIFENZHUNQUE,HUOZHESHUO,QIZHINENGZAIMOUZHONGYIYISHANGCHENGLI。YINWEIYUTANBAICONGKUANZHENGCEXIANGBI,RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUJUYOUDUTEDEZHIDUNEIHANHENEIZAILUOJI。TANBAICONGKUANGUANCHUANLETESHUYUFANGDESIXIANG,QISHIYONGYAOQIUFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENRENZUIQIEHUIZUI;RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDETUIXINGZEGENGDUODESHIJIYUXIANSHIZHUYIDEKAOLV,SHIWEILETIGAODAJIFANZUIDEXIAONENG、JIEYUESIFAZIYUANERGEIGONGANSIFAJIGUANTIGONGDEYIGEYONGYIHEFADIYOUDAOFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENYUYIHEZUODEZHIDULIQI,ZAIRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUKUANGJIAXIA,JIBIANFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZHUGUANSHANGBINGWEIZHENCHENGHUIZUI,DANZHIYAOQIYOURENZUIRENFADEXINGWEI,ZAIKEGUANSHANG“BIAOMING”HUIZUI,9JIKEXIANGSHOUBEICONGKUANCHULIDEQUANLI。

  ZUIHOU,XINGSHISUSONGFADI182TIAOGUIDINGDETESHUDECAILIANGBUQISUJINGUANKEYIJIANGSHIJIANZHONGKEGUANCUNZAIDEYIBUFENKONGBIANJIAOYIXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISUXIANXIANGYUYIHEFAHUA,DANYOUQIYANGEDESHIYONGTIAOJIANHESHIYONGCHENGXUSUOJUEDING,CIZHONGTESHUDECAILIANGBUQISUBUNENGBEIYONGYICHULISHIJIANZHONGDEDADUOSHUKONGBIANJIAOYIXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEI,HUANWUFAWEIZHEXIEKONGBIANJIAOYIXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEITIGONGZHENGDANGHUAGENJU。

  五、認罪認罰從寬制度的推行加大了選擇性不起訴的濫用風險

  RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDETUIXING,XIANRANJIADALEXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANYONGFENGXIAN,YINERXUYAOGEIYUZUGOUDERENSHIHEZHONGSHI。

秒速赛车6码计划   SHOUXIAN,DUIYURENZUIRENFADEFANZUIXIANYIREN,JIANCHAJIGUANCHUKEYIZUOCHUZHUODINGBUQISUHUOZHEFUTIAOJIANBUQISU(WEICHENGNIANRENFANZUIANJIAN)DEJUEDINGWAI,RUQIANSUOSHU,2018NIANXIUZHENGHOUDEXIN《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DI182TIAOYOUFUYUJIANCHAJIGUANYIZHONGXINDECAILIANGBUQISUQUAN,JIZHIYAOFANZUIXIANYIRENZIYUANRUSHIGONGSHUSHEXIANFANZUIDESHISHI,QIEYOUZHONGDALIGONGHUOZHEANJIANSHEJIGUOJIAZHONGDALIYI,NEIMEJINGZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANPIZHUN,JIANCHAJIGUANKEYIBUSHOUFANZUIQINGZHONGCHENGDUDEXIANZHI,ZUOCHUBUQISUJUEDING,HUOZHEDUISHEXIANSHUZUIZHONGDEYIXIANGHUOZHEDUOXIANGBUQISU。YOUCI,JIANCHAJIGUANBUJINZAIQINGZUIANJIANZHONGXIANGYOUXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEQUANLI,ZAIMOUXIEZHONGZUIANJIANZHONGYEKEYIDUIFANZUIXIANYIRENHUOZHEFANZUIXINGWEIXUANZEXINGDIBUYUQISU。RUGUOKAOLVDAOQIZHONGKENENGHANGAIDEKONGBIANXIESHANGQINGXING,ZEKEYISHUO,WOGUOLIFAYIJINGQUELILEJIANCHAJIGUANDUIYUZHONGZUIANJIANDEXIESHANGQUANLI。10CIWAI,HEWEI“RENZUI”?HEWEI“ZHONGDALIGONG”?HEWEI“GUOJIAZHONGDALIYI”?RUCIDENGDENG,DOUSHEJIHENQIANGDEZHUGUANPANDUANHERENDINGWENTI,YINERCUNZAIJIAODADECAILIANGKONGJIAN。ZHEXIEWUYIDADATUOZHANLEJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELINGYUHEKONGJIAN。NANGUAIYOUXUEZHERENWEI,TUIJINRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDEJIHUMEIYIGEJUCUODOUHUISHEJIJIANCHAJIGUAN,ERQIEJIHUWUYILIWAIDIHUIDAOZHIJIANCHAJIGUANQUANLIDEKUOZHANG。[19]ERWULUNSHIJIYUXUELIHUANSHISHIJIANLAIFENXI,DOUBUNANRENSHIDAO,QUANLIDEKUOZHANGBIRANBANSUIZHULANYONGFENGXIANDEZENGJIA。

  QICI,BANSUIZHURENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDETUIXING,“SANFANGHEZUO”SUSONGMOSHIJIANCIXINGCHENG。JUTISHUOLAI,WEILEMANZURENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDESHIYONGTIAOJIAN,BUJINKONGBIANSHUANGFANGZHIJIANYAOJINXINGXIESHANGYUHEZUO,SHENPANJIGUANYUKONGBIANSHUANGFANGZHIJIANYEKENENGHUIZAISHISHIRENDINGHELIANGXINGFANGMIANJINXING“XIESHANG”[20]P29YUHEZUO,YOUCIJIUXINGCHENGLEKONGBIANSHEN“SANFANGHEZUO”SUSONGMOSHI。ZAIZHEZHONGSUSONGMOSHIZHONG,TUICHONGHEZUOSHIGONGSU、HEZUOSHIBIANHUYUHEZUOSHISHENPANLINIAN,JUYOUJIAOQIANGDEZHUNJIUWENSHISIFAHELIUSHUIXIANSHISIFASECAI11:KONG、SHENJIGUANZAISUSONGJINCHENGZHONGFAHUIZHUZHUDAOXINGZUOYONG,FANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENJIQIBIANHURENHUOZHIBANLVSHIJIBENSHANGCHUYUPEIHEHEFUCONGDEZHUANGTAI,BEIDONGDIGENZHUKONG、SHENJIGUANDEBUZIPAO,TAOJIAHUANJIADEYUDIHUANSHIBIJIAOXIAODE,GENGBUYAOSHUOQIXIESHANGNENGLISHOUZHIYUZHENGTISHANGJIAORUODEBIANHULVSHIHUOZHIBANLVSHIDESHUIPING、JINGYANHEZERENXIN。

  “SANFANGHEZUO”SUSONGMOSHIZAIJIAKUAISUSONGLIUCHENG,BAOZHANGFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENTONGGUORENZUIRENFAHUODECONGKUANCHULIFANGMIANJUYOUJIJIDEXIAOYONG,DANTONGSHIYEYINQIANGHUALEGONG、JIAN、FA、BIANZHIJIANDEXIANGHUPEIHE,RUOHUALEDUIZHEN、KONG、SHENQUANLIDEZHIYUE,ERSHIDEGONGJIANFAQUANLIDEXINGSHIGENGJIALINGHUO,YEGENGRONGYICHUXIANLANYONGDEWENTI。YIFANGMIAN,ZAIWEITUOBIANHULVJIDI、FALVYUANZHUFANWEIXIANGDUIYOUXIAN、ZHIBANLVSHICHANGCHANGNANYIYOUXIAOTIGONGFALVBANGZHUDEBEIJINGXIA,JIANCHAJIGUANJIYILIYONGDIWEI、ZIYUAN、ZHUANYEDENGFANGMIANDEYOUSHIQIANGPOHUOYOUPIANFANZUIXIANYIRENRENZUI,CONGERCHUXIANYUANJIWUGUHUOZHEDAJIGUOZHONGDEXIANXIANG。12LINGYIFANGMIAN,KENENGHUIJIAJUJIANCHAJIGUANLANXINGXUANZEXINGBUQISUCONGERWEIGUIFANGZONGHUOZHEQINGZONGFANZUIXIANYIRENDEXIANXIANG,SUNHAISIFAPINGDENGYUANZE。ZAIZHEFANGMIAN,YUWAIDEJIAOXUNZHIDEXIQU。BIRU,ZAIBIANSUJIAOYIZHIDUXINGZHIDUONIANDEMEIGUO,YOUYANJIUJIUZHICHU,95%DEXINGSHIBEIGAORENHUIZAIWANMEIDEBIANSUJIAOYITIXIZHONGXUANZERENZUI,DANSHITAMENJIESHOUDEJIAOYITIAOKUANKANSHANGQUKENENGHENBUXIANGTONG,NIANLING、XINGBIE、CAIFU、ZHILI、LVSHISHUIPINGHEZILIQINGXIANGYIJIQITABUXIANGGUANDEYINSUHUIDAOZHIZHENGYIFENPEIBUGONG,YINERXINGFAFENPEI、QUANLIHEBUPINGDENGDENGYITIYINGGAIHUODEGENGDUODEGUANZHU。[21]P82

  ZUIHOU,XUYAOTEBIEZHICHUDESHI,2018NIANXIUZHENGHOUDEXIN《XINGSHISUSONGFA》JIANGDI182TIAOANPAIZAIDISANZHANGTIQIGONGSUDEZUIHOUYITIAO,GENJUTIXIJIESHIDEYUANLI,DI182TIAOGUIDINGDETESHUDECAILIANGBUQISUJIUBUNENGSHIYONGDI179TIAOGUANYUGONGANJIGUANDUIBUQISUJUEDINGDEYIYI、DI180TIAOGUANYUBEIHAIRENDUIBUQISUJUEDINGDEYIYI、DI181TIAOGUANYUBEIBUQISURENDUIBUQISUJUEDINGDEYIYIDENGTIAOKUANDEGUIDING。YEJIUSHISHUO,CIZHONGTESHUDECAILIANGBUQISUQUANLIZHIWAIZAIYUESHUGENGJIABORUO,XINGSHISUSONGFABINGMEIYOUFUYUGONGANJIGUAN、BEIHAIRENHEBEIBUQISURENDUIQITICHUYIYIHEJINXINGZHIYUEDEQUANLI/LI,ERWANQUANWEIZHUYUJIANCHAXITONGNEIBUDEZIWOBAGUANHEZIWOKONGZHI(XUJINGZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANPIZHUN)。BUGUO,GENJUZHENGZHIXUEDEJIBENGUILV,DANKAOJIANCHAXITONGNEIDEZILVKENENGHENNANYOUXIAOKONGZHIXUANZEXINGBUQISUQUANLIDELANYONG。

  六、認罪認罰從寬制度背景下選擇性不起訴的法律規制

  WEIBAOZHANGRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDEHELIYUNXING,TISHENGJIANCHAZHIFAGONGXINLI,YINGDANGWEIYUCHOUMOU,CAIQUDUOZHONGCUOSHIGUIZHIJIANCHAJIGUANDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEI,FANGFANQIKENENGCHUXIANDELANYONG。

秒速赛车6码计划   BIRU,TONGGUOSIFAZERENZHI、SHENGJIYIXIARENMINJIANCHAYUANRENCAIWUTONGYIGUANLIDENGGAIGE,JIANQUANJIANCHAQUANDEDULIXINGSHIJIZHI;WANSHANJIANCHAZHIYELUNLIJIAOYUHEZHIYECHENGJIECUOSHI,GUIZHIJIANCHARENYUANDEDAODEFENGXIAN;JIAQIANGJIANCHAJIGUANNEIBUDEJIANDUZHIYUE;WANSHANRENMINJIANDUYUANJIANDUZHIDU,JIANQUANBUQISUDESHEHUIJIANDU;YOUQISHIYAOQIANGHUABUQISUJUEDINGSHUDESHUOLIHEGONGKAI13,WANSHANBUQISUJUEDINGDEGONGKAIXUANGAOHETINGZHENGZHIDU,DENGDENG。YIXIAJIANGZHUYAOCONGFALVCENGMIANTANTAOXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEGUIZHICUOSHI。

秒速赛车6码计划   1.FEICHU“GONGSUZHUANZISU”ZHIDU,GOUJIANZHUNQISUCHENGXUHEFAGUANSHIQIANTONGYIZHIDU,WANSHANFAYUANDUIJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUDEZHIYUEJIZHI

秒速赛车6码计划   CONGLILUNSHANGJIANG,XUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGJIBAOKUOWEIFANQISUFADINGZHUYIYUANZEDE“GAISUERBUSU”XINGWEI,YEBAOKUOBEILIQISUBIANYIZHUYIYUANZEDE“YISUERBUSU”XINGWEI。ZAIFANGZHIHEKONGZHIJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANXINGFANGMIAN,GEGUOPUBIANJIAOWEIZHONGSHIFAYUANDEJIERUHEGONGNENGFAHUI,BINGDAZHICHENGXIANWEISANZHONGDAIBIAOXINGDEMOSHI:

  YISHIYINGMEIGUOJIADEFAGUANZHIHENGMOSHI。YINGMEIFAYUANDUIYUJIANCHAGUANZUOCHUDEBUQISUCHUFEN,YIBANBUHUIJIERUHESHENCHA。YINGMEIXUEJIEPUBIANJIANGJIANCHAGUANDECAILIANGBUQISUSHIWEIYIFANGDANGSHIRENDEQISUQUANCHUFENXINGWEI,BUXUYAOFAYUANDETONGYIHUOJIERUSHENCHA,ERQIEFAYUANSHENCHAJIANCHAGUANDECAILIANGBUQISUQUANYEBEIRENWEIWEIFANSANQUANFENLIYUANZE。YIJUQUANLIFENLIYUANZE,SIFABUFUZEHEMUDEXINGWENTIDEJUECE,ERZHIJINXINGHEFAXINGSHENCHA。MEIGUOLIANBANGZUIGAOFAYUANJIURENWEI,JIANCHAJIGUANGUANGFANDECAILIANGQUANZAIHENDACHENGDUSHANGYILAIYUZHEZHONGRENSHI,JIQISUJUEDINGYOUQINANYUSHOUDAOSIFASHENCHA。ANJIANZHENGJUSHIFOUYOULI、JIANKONGFANGDEYIBANYUFANGJIAZHIGUAN、ZHENGFUZHIFAQUXIANG、ANJIANYUZHENGFUZONGTIZHIFAJIHUADEGUANXIDENGYINSU,BINGBUSHIFAYUANSUOSHANCHANGDEFENXIMOSHINENGGOUYINGDUIDE。CIWAI,ZHEYILINGYUDESIFAJIANDUDAILAIDEZHIDUCHENGBENYOUQIZHIDEGUANZHU。[22]JIYUCI,DUIYUBUQISUDEJUEDING,JIANCHAGUANBUBISHUOMINGLIYOU,BEIHAIRENYIBANBUXIANGYOUXIANGGUANDEJIUJITUJING,FAYUANTONGCHANGYEWUQUANDUIJIANCHAGUANDEJUEDINGJINXINGGANYUHEKONGZHI。BUGUO,JINXIENIANLAI,WEIHUIYINGRIYIQIANGDADEBEIHAIRENQUANLIBAOHUYUNDONG,MEIGUOYIXIEZHOUKAISHIYAOQIUJIANCHAGUANTIGONGSHUMIANDEBUQISULIYOU,YUNXUSIFAFUSHEN,SHOUQUANFAYUANMINGLINGJIANCHAGUANDUIBUQISUDEANJIANTIQIGONGSUHUOZHERENMINGYIGETEBIEJIANCHAGUAN。BIRU,Ala. Code sec. 12-17-186(1986)GUIDING:DANGDIQUJIANCHAGUANJUJUEQISUSHI,FAYUANKEYIRENMINGYIGESHIGEDEJIANCHAGUANDAITIGAIDIQUJIANCHAGUANQISU;Colo. Rev. Stat. Sec. 16-5-209(1990)GUIDING,RUGUOTINGSHENHOU,FAGUANQUERENJIANCHAGUANDEBUQISUJUEDINGSHIWUDUANDEHUOZHEFANFUWUCHANGDEBINGQIEMEIYOUHELIDELIYOUSHI,TAKEYIMINGLINGGAIJIANCHAGUANQISUHUOZHERENMINGYIMINGTEBIEDEJIANCHAGUANQISU;Mich. Comp. Laws sec. 767.41(1990)GUIDING,JIANCHAGUANBIXUWEIBUQISUTIGONGSHUMIANLIYOU,RUGUOFAYUANBUMANYIQISHUOMING,JIANGZHISHIJIANCHAGUANTIQIGONGSU,DENGDENG。

  ERSHIDALUFAXIGUOJIADEFAGUANZHIHENGMOSHI。DALUFAXIGUOJIACHUANTONGSHANGSHIJIANCHAGUANWEISIFAGUAN,YINCIFAYUANKONGZHIBUQISUCAILIANGQUANBUCUNZAILILUNZHANGAI。ZHENGRUYOUXUEZHEZHICHUDE,DUIJIANCHAGUANQISUHUANSHIBUQISUDEJUEDINGDESIFASHENCHABINGBUMIANDUIFENQUANYUANZEDEZHIYUE;[23]JIANCHAGUANSHISHISHANGBEIRENWEISHISIFAJIAOSE,FUYOUYUFAGUANXIANGTONGDEPINGHENG、GONGZHENGLVXINGQIZHIZEDEZHIYEYIWU。[24]YIDEGUOWEILI,DUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANDEBUQISUXINGWEI,QUFENLIANGZHONGQINGKUANGSHEJILEBUTONGDEFAGUANZHIHENGZHIDU:(1)DUIYUWEIFANQISUFADINGZHUYIYUANZEERGAISUBUSUDEXINGWEI,CAIQUQIANGZHIQISUCHENGXUJINXINGZHIYUE。DEGUOXINGSHISUSONGFADI170TIAO-176TIAOGUIDING,JIANCHAJIGUANBUZHICHITIQIGONGSUHUOZHEZHENCHAZHONGJIEHOUTINGZHICHENGXUDEJUEDINGBIXUTONGZHIBEIGAORENHEGAOSUREN,RUGUOGAOSURENTONGSHISHIBEIHAIRENSHI,ZEYOUQUANZAITONGZHIHOUDELIANGZHOUNEIXIANGJIANCHAYUANDESHANGJIGUANYUANKANGGAO。RUGUOGAISHANGJIGUANYUANTONGYIDIFANGJIANCHAYUANDEJUEDING,ZEGAOSURENYOUQUANZAITONGZHIHOUYIGEYUENEISHENQINGZHOUGAODENGFAYUANCAIPAN。YAOQIUFAYUANCAIPANDESHENQINGSHUBIXUXIEMINGRENWEIYINGDANGTIQIGONGSUDESHISHI,TICHUZHENGJU。SHENQINGSHUBIXUYOUYIMINGLVSHIQIANMING。RUGUOZHOUGAODENGFAYUANZAITISHENBEIGAORENZHIHOU,RENWEIBEIHAIRENDESHENQINGCHENGLI,JIUDUIJIANCHAGUANFABUQIANGZHILING,YAOQIUTADUIBEIGAORENTICHUZHIKONG。RANHOUJIANCHAGUANYOUZERENTIQIGONGSU,GAOSURENKEYIZUOWEIFUZHUJIANCHAGUANCANJIAANJIAN。CIWAI,DUISHENQINGZUOCHUCAIDINGQIAN,FAYUANKEYICAIDINGYAOQIUGAOSUREN,DUICHENGXUGEIGUOKUHEBEIZHIKONGRENYUJICHANSHENGDEFEIYONGTIGONGDANBAO。14(2)DUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANCAILIANGBUQISUDEXINGWEI,ZECAIQUFAGUANSHIXIANSHENCHADEFANGSHIJIAYIZHIYUE。GENJUDEGUOXINGSHISUSONGFADI153TIAO15、DI153TIAOa16DENGTIAOKUANDEGUIDING,JIANCHAJIGUANZAIZUOCHUZHUODINGBUQISU、FUTIAOJIANBUQISUDEGUOCHENGZHONG,TONGCHANGXUYAOZHENGDEXIANGYINGDEGUANXIAFAYUANDETONGYI。[25]P147-149

  SANSHIRIBENDEFAGUANZHIHENGMOSHI。RIBENJIANCHAGUANZAIZUOCHUBUQISUCAILIANGJUEDINGHOU,BEIHAIRENRUGUOBUFU,KEYIFADONGZHUNQISUCHENGXU(YOUCHENGFUSHENPANQINGQIUCHENGXU),SHENQINGFAYUANDUIJIANCHAGUANDEBUQISUCAILIANGJUEDINGJINXINGSIFASHENCHA。JUTIERYAN,ZAIGONGWUYUANLANYONGZHIQUANZUIDENGQINFANRENQUANDEANJIANZHONG,RUGUOFANZUIKONGGAORENDENGDUIYUJIANCHAGUANDEBUQISUCAILIANGJUEDINGBUFU,KEYICONGJIEDAOBUQISUCHUFENTONGZHIZHIRIQI7TIANYINEI,QINGQIUJIANGANJIANJIAOFUFAYUANSHENPAN,FAYUANDUISHANGSHUQINGQIUSHENLIHOU,BOHUIQINGQIUHUOZHEJIANGANJIANTIJIAOFAYUANSHENPAN;FAYUANRUGUOZUOCHUJIAOFUSHENPANDEJUEDING,JIUKEYISHIWEITIQIGONGSU,ZHESHI,FAYUANYINGDANGZHIDINGLVSHIDANRENJIANCHAGUANZHIWU。BEIZHIDINGDELVSHIZAISHENPANQUEDINGQIAN,ZHIXINGJIANCHAGUANDEZHIWU,DANGUANYUZHIHUIJIANCHASHIWUGUANHUOSIFAJINGCHA(GUAN)JINXINGDIAOCHADESHIXIANG,YINGWEITUOJIANCHAGUANJINXING,FAYUANRENWEILVSHIBUSHIYUZHIXINGZHIWUSHI,KEYISUISHICHEXIAOZHIDINGHUOZHEGENGHUANLVSHI,GENGHUANLVSHIHOUBUYINGXIANGYUANLVSHISUOJINXINGDESUSONGXINGWEIDEXIAOLI,WUXUGENGXINCHENGXU。RIBENZHUNQISUCHENGXUYUDEGUOQIANGZHIQISUCHENGXUYOUXIELEISI,DANYECUNZAIRUXIADEQUBIE:[26](1)SHIYONGANJIANFANWEIFANGMIAN,DEGUOFADUIYUSHIYONGQIANGZHIQISUCHENGXUDEFANZUILEIXINGYUANZESHANGBINGWUXIANZHI,RIBENFAZEJINXIANYUGONGWUYUANLANYONGZHIQUANZUIDETEDINGANJIANFANWEI。(2)SHENQINGQUANRENDEFANWEIFANGMIAN,DEGUOFAZHONGSHENQINGFAYUANQIANGZHIQISUDEZHUTIXIANYUBEIHAIREN,RIBENFAZEWEIGONGWUYUANLANYONGZHIQUANANJIANDEBEIHAIRENJIGAOFAREN(CINAIYINGONGWUYUANZHIQUANFANZUI,RENHERENDOUKEYIGAOFA)。(3)GUANXIAFAYUANDESHENJIFANGMIAN,DEGUOFAZHONGQIANGZHIQISUDESHENQINGXIYOUGAODENGFAYUANGUANXIA,RIBENJIAOFUSHENPANDESHENQINGZEYOUDIFANGFAYUANYIHEYITINGFANGSHISHENCHA。(4)FAYUANSHENCHADEXINGZHIFANGMIAN,DEGUOTONGSHUORENWEIGUANYUSHENQINGYOUWULIYOUDESHENCHASHUYUZHENCHAXINGZHI,DANRIBENDEDUOSHUJIANJIEZERENWEIFAYUANSHIFOUCAIDINGWEIJIAOFUSHENPANDESHENCHAXIJUYOUZHONGJIANXINGZHIDEQINGQIUSHEN。(5)ZAIXINGZHUISUDEZHUTIFANGMIAN,DEGUOFAYUANRENWEISHENQINGYOULIYOU,ANJIANYINGYUYIZHUISUDE,RENGWEICHIYOUJIANCHAGUANSUIXINGGONGSUDEXINGTAI,GUCHENGWEIQIANGZHIQISU,DANZAIRIBENZEZHIDINGLVSHIDAITIBEIHAIRENDENGSHIXINGZHUISU,GUJIAOFUSHENPANNAIJIANCHAGUANGONGSUDUZHANDELIWAI。(6)MUDEJIYUANLIFANGMIAN,RIBENDEZHUNQISUZHIDUXIZHENDUIZHENCHAHUODIAOCHAJIGUANQINHAIRENQUANDETEDINGANJIANSUOZENGSHEDEJIUJIJIZHI,ZHUYAOMUDESHIZAIFANGZHIJIANCHAGUANZHENBANGONGWUYUANLANYONGZHIQUANANJIANKENENGGUANGUANXIANGHUDEBIDUAN,ERQIEBEIHAIRENYUYIBANGUOMINDOUKEYIZUOWEIGAOFAREN,TONGSHIZHIDINGBIANHURENSHIXINGZHUISU,ZHEXIEDOUTIXIANLESIFAMINZHUHUADELINIAN。DEGUOQIANGZHIQISUZHIDUZEZHUYAOSHIJIYUQUANLIZHIHENGDESIXIANGSHELI。

  CONGWOGUODEQINGKUANGKAN,2018NIANXIUZHENGHOUDEXIN《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DI180TIAOYEGUIDINGLEBEIHAIRENDUIJIANCHAJIGUANDEBUQISUJUEDINGSHENQINGFAYUANJIUJIDECHENGXU(DI182TIAOGUIDINGDETESHUDECAILIANGBUQISUCHUWAI),JIBEIHAIRENKEYIXIANGSHANGYIJIJIANCHAJIGUANSHENSU,RANHOUXIANGFAYUANQISU,HUOZHEZHIJIEXIANGFAYUANQISU。BUGUO,SHIJIANBIAOMING,YOUYUBEIHAIRENSHOUJIZHENGJUDENENGLIWANGWANGCUNZAIHENDAWENTI,YINERHENSHAONENGGOUSHUOFUFAYUANYUYILIAN,GENGBUYAOSHUOSHIFAYUANDUIBEIGAORENZUOCHUYOUZUIPANJUE。HUANYANZHI,FALVFUYUBEIHAIRENDE“GONGSUZHUANZISU”QUANLIZAISHIJIANZHONGJIBENSHANGLUNWEILE“JINGZHONGHUA,SHUIZHONGYUE”,JIBENBUJUXIANSHIKEXINGXING。JIANCI,BENWENRENWEI,YINGDANGJINKUAIFEICHUXIANXINGDEGONGSUZHUANZISUZHIDU,WANSHANFAYUANDUIJIANCHAJIGUANBUQISUDEZHIYUEJIZHI。

  YIFANGMIAN,DUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANNIZUOCHUDECAILIANGXINGBUQISUJUEDING,TONGGUOXIUFAQUELIYOUFAYUANSHIXIANSHENCHABINGJUEDINGTONGYIYUFOUDEZHIDU,YIQUEBAOBUFANGZONGFANZUI,WEIHUBEIHAIRENDEHEFALIYI。JIANCHAJIGUANZAICAIQUXINGSHISUSONGFADI182TIAOSUOGUIDINGDETESHUDECAILIANGBUQISUXINGWEISHI,YEYINGYOUFAYUANSHIXIANSHENCHATONGYI,JIZAIZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANPIZHUNZHIHOUHUANYINGZHENGDEZUIGAORENMINFAYUANDETONGYI。CIWAI,WEIHELIJIANGUBEIBUQISURENHEFAQUANYIDEBAOZHANG,JIANCHAJIGUANZAIZUOCHUCAILIANGXINGBUQISUJUEDINGZHIQIAN,HUANBIXUQUDEBEIBUQISURENDETONGYI。

秒速赛车6码计划   LINGYIFANGMIAN,DUIYUWEIFANQISUFADINGZHUYIDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEI,KEYIJIEJIANRIBENDEJINGYAN,GOUJIANZHUNQISUCHENGXUJIAYIZHIYUE。LIYOUZAIYU,JIAOZHIYUDEGUODEQIANGZHIQISUCHENGXU,RIBENDEZHUNQISUCHENGXUGENGJIEJINYUZISU,QIEYOULVSHICHENGDANQISUZHINENG,JIAOZHIYUYOUJIANCHAGUANQISUGENGNENGBIMIANJIANCHAGUANXIEDAIZHUISUDEWENTI。JUTICHENGXUKEYISHEJIRUXIA:DUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANWEIFANQISUFADINGZHUYIDEXUANZEXINGBUQISUXINGWEI,BEIHAIRENKEYIXIANGSHANGYIJIJIANCHAJIGUANSHENSU,SHANGJIJIANCHAJIGUANJUJUETIQIGONGSUHOU,KEYIXIANGGAIJIANCHAJIGUANSUOZAIDEDIFANGFAYUANDIJIAOJIAOFUSHENPANDESHENQINGSHU。DUIYUBEIHAIRENDESHENQING,FAYUANKEYIZUOCHUBOHUISUSONGQINGQIUHUOZHEJIAOFUSHENPANDECAIDING。RUGUOFAYUANZUOCHUJIAOFUSHENPANDECAIDING,JIANGANJIANYISONGGUANXIAFAYUANSHENPAN,ZESHIWEIYIXIANGFAYUANTIQISUSONG,QIXIAOLIDENGTONGYUJIANCHAJIGUANTIQIGONGSU,YOUFAYUANZHIDINGDELVSHIDANRENGONGSUJIANCHAGUAN,BEIZHIDINGDELVSHISHIWEIYIZHAOFALVCONGSHIGONGWUDERENYUAN,YOUQUANCONGGUOJIALINGQUXIANGYINGDEBAOCHOU。ZHEYANGYILAI,DUIYUCUNZAIBEIHAIRENDEJIANCHAJIGUANXUANZEXINGBUQISUANJIAN,BEIHAIRENTONGGUOQIDONGZHUNQISUCHENGXU,BUJINKEYIYOUXIAOBAITUO“GONGSUZHUANZISU”CHENGXUZHONGPUBIANCUNZAIDEBEIHAIRENQUZHENGNAN、JUZHENGNAN、FAYUANSHOULINANDENGKUNJING,YEKEYIBIMIAN“QIANGRENSUONAN”DIYAOQIUJIANCHAJIGUANTIQIGONGSUSUOKENENGDAOZHIDEXIAOJIGONGSUWENTI,SHIXIANLEBEIHAIRENQUANYIBAOHUYUDAJIFANZUIDEYOUJITONGYI。17DANGRAN,WEIFANGZHIBEIHAIRENLANYONGSUQUAN,KEYIJIEJIANDERIJINGYAN,JIANGOUSUSONGFEIYONGZHIDU,GUIDINGFAYUANBUSHOULIBEIHAIRENTIQIDEJIAOFUSHENPANQINGQIUDE,KEYITONGSHICAIDINGMINGLINGBEIHAIRENFUDANYINYUCIQINGQIUYOUGUANDECHENGXUSUOCHANSHENGFEIYONGDEQUANBUHUOZHEYIBUFEN。

  2.WANSHANRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDU,GOUJIANWUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDU,JIEJUEKONGBIANXIESHANG“LIANGXINGWEIFA”DEWENTI

秒速赛车6码计划   QIYI,WANSHANRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUYOUQISHIZHIBANLVSHIZHIDU。RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUZAIMOUZHONGYIYISHANGQUELILEJIANCHAJIGUANYUBEIZHUISURENYIFANGKAIZHANXIESHANGXINGHUODONGDEQUANLI。BUGUO,ZHENGRUMEIGUOXUEZHEZAIDUIBEIZHUISURENRENZUIANJIANDEYANJIUZHONGSUOZHICHUDE,SUIRANBEIZHUISURENMINGYISHANGXIANGYOURENZUIHUOBURENZUIDEJUEDUIQUANLI,DANSHITAMENJINGCHANGHUIFAXIAN,ZAIMEIYOUBIANHURENDEQINGKUANGXIAZIJIGENBENBUXIANGYOURENHEBAOHU。[27]P6SHENYANZHI,ZAIRENZUIRENFACONGKUANANJIANZHONG,BIXUCAIQUJIJICUOSHIQUEBAOFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENNENGGOUHUODELVSHIYOUXIAODEBIANHU,FANGZHIJIANCHAJIGUANLIYONGZIJIDEZHUANYEYOUSHIHEQIANGSHIDIWEIQIANGPOHUOZHEYOUPIANFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENBUZIYUANHUOZHEBULIZHIDIRENZUI,BIMIANFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENBENLAIWUGUQUE“ZIYUAN”RENZUIDEQINGKUANGFASHENG。WEICI,ZHENDUIWOGUODANGQIANRENZUIRENFAANJIANBANLISHIJIANZHONGZHIBANLVSHIDE“JIANZHENGRENHUA”HEFALVBANGZHUBULIWENTI,YINGDANGZAISHENRUDIAOYANDEJICHUSHANG,GAIGEZHIBANLVSHIZHIDU,TIGAOZHIBANLVSHIDEFALVDIWEI,ZENGJIAZHIBANLVSHIDESUSONGQUANLI,JINERJIANG“WEIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENTIGONGFALVZIXUN、CHENGXUXUANZEJIANYI、SHENQINGBIANGENGQIANGZHICUOSHI、DUIANJIANCHULITICHUYIJIANDENGFALVBANGZHU”(XINGSHISUSONGFADI36TIAO)DEZHIBANLVSHIGAIZAOCHENGWEIXIANGYOUCHONGFENDEHUIJIAN、YUEJUAN、DIAOCHAQUZHENG、XIESHANG、CANYUFATINGDIAOCHABIANLUNDENGSUSONGQUANLIDEBIANHUREN,YISHIXIANLVSHIBIANHUDEQUANMIANXINGHEYOUXIAOXING,WEIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENTIGONGSHIZHI、YOUXIAODEFALVBANGZHU,QIANGHUALVSHIJIERUDUIJIANCHAGUANBUQISUCAILIANGQUANXINGSHIDEJIANDUZHIYUEZUOYONG,BAOZHENGFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENRENZUIRENFADEHEFAXING、ZIYUANXINGHELIZHIXING。

秒速赛车6码计划   QIER,JIANGSHIJIANZHONGJIANCHAJIGUANSHICHANGCAIQUDE“WUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIAN”ZUOFAFALVHUA、GUIFANHUA,YIJIEJUETANWUHUILUFANZUI、DUPINFANZUI、HEISHEHUIXINGZHIZUZHIFANZUIDENGANJIANZHONGDEQUZHENGNANWENTI,TIGAOJIANCHAJIGUANDEZHIKONGCHENGXIAO。

秒速赛车6码计划   WUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDUSHIZHISIFAJIGUANZAIZHUISUFANZUIGUOCHENGZHONG,WEIQUDEMOUXIEZHONGYAODEFANZUIZHENGJUHUOZHEZHUIJIUZHUFANDEYANZHONGZUIXING,DUIANJIANZHONGZUIXINGJIAOQINGWEIZHEZUOCHUCHENGNUO,ZAITAMENXIANGSIFAJIGUANTIGONGSHIZHIXINGPEIHEHEBANGZHUHOU,JIANGJIANQINGHUOZHEMIANCHUQIXINGSHIZERENDEYIZHONGZHIDU。CONGLILUNSHANGJIANG,WUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANBAOKUOLIANGZHONGLEIXING:YISHIZUIXINGHUOMIAN,ERSHIZHENGJUSHIYONGHUOMIAN。[28]CICHUZHUYAOSHUODESHIZUIXINGHUOMIAN。GENJUFAJIESHIXUEDEYUANLI,XINGSHISUSONGFADI182TIAOGUANYUFANZUIXIANYIRENYOUZHONGDALIGONGSHIKEYIZUOCHEXIAOANJIANHUOZHEBUQISUCHULIDEGUIDINGSHIZHISHANGYIJINGBUFENDIBAOHANLEWUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANDENEIRONG,ZHIBUGUOGAITIAOGUIDINGSHIYONGDEANJIANLEIXINGYOUXIEGUOYUKUANFAN(MEIYOUZUORENHEXIANDING),ERQIESHIYONGCHENGXUTEBIEYANGE。WUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDUDEQUELIHESHIYONGJINGUANYOUYIYUMANZUSIFAJIGUANQIANGLIEDEXIANSHIBANANXUQIU,BANGZHUSIFAJIGUANZAIQUZHENGKUNNANDEQINGKUANGXIACHENGGONGSHIXIANDUILIFAZHONGDIANDAJIDEYANZHONGXINGSHIFANZUIXINGWEIDEYOUXIAOZHUISUHECHENGZHI,HELIPEIZHISIFAZIYUAN,DANSHIWUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDUBIJINGSHIYIDUIMOUXIEZUIXINGQINGWEIZHECHENGFADEFANGQILAISHIXIANCHENGFAYANZHONGZUIXINGHUOZHEZHUYAOFANZUIZHEDEMUDE,HUOZHESHUO,TONGGUOXISHENGJIAOXIAODESIFALIYILAIWEIHUGENGDADESIFALIYI,YINERQISHISHIBIRANHUIBUTONGCHENGDUDICHONGJIHEQINSHISIFAPINGDENG、QISUFADINGZHUYI、ZUIZEXINGXIANGSHIYINGDENGXINGSHIFAYUANZE,QIEJUYOUJIAODADELANYONGFENGXIAN,YINERJIYUFAYIQUANHENGDEYUANLI,YINGDANGDUIWUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDUZUOCHUANJIANLEIXINGDEXIANZHI。JUCI,JIANYIZAIXIANXINGLIFAJICHUSHANG,QUFENBUTONGDEANJIANLEIXINGSHEZHIDUOYUANHUADEWUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDU:QIYI,YUANZESHANG,WUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDUZHISHIYONGYUANJIANZHONGDEZUIXINGQINGWEIZHEHUOZHEZAIGONGTONGFANZUIZHONGCHUYUCONGFANHUOZHEXIECONGFANDIWEIDEFANZUIXIANYIREN,ERQIEQISHISHIYINGDANGBAOJINGSHANGYIJIJIANCHAYUANPIZHUN。WEIJIANGU“BUWANGBUZONG”DESUSONGJIAZHIZHUIQIU,FANGFANKENENGZISHENGDEFENGXIANHEWEIHAI,YINGDANGHELIKONGZHIWUDIANZHENGRENZUOZHENGHUOMIANZHIDUDEANJIANSHIYONGFANWEI,JIANGQIXIANDINGZAIZHONGDATANWUHUILUFANZUI、DUPINFANZUI、HEISHEHUIXINGZHIDEZUZHIFANZUI、WEIHAIGUOJIAANQUANFANZUI、KONGBUHUODONGFANZUIJIQITAJUYOUYANZHONGSHEHUIWEIHAIXING、SHEHUIYINGXIANGJIAODADETUANHUOFANZUIANJIANZHONG。QIER,ZUOWEISHAOSHULIWAI,KEYISHIYONGYUSHANGSHUFANZUIANJIANYIWAIDEZUIXINGQINGWEIZHEHUOZHEGONGTONGFANZUIZHONGDEZHUFAN,JUTIZEYIJUDI182TIAODEGUIDINGCHULI。CIWAI,WEIFANGZHIWUDIANZHENGRENBEIHUOMIANYIHOUTIGONGXUJIADEZHENGYAN,LIFAYINGDANGTONGSHIQUELIXIANGYINGDECHENGJIEZHIDU,JIRUGUOCHUXIANZHEZHONGQINGKUANG,ZEJIANGWUDIANZHENGRENBEIHUOMIANDEZUIXINGYUWEIZHENGZUIYIBINGJIAYIZHUISU。

秒速赛车6码计划   3.FUYUBUQISUYIDINGDESHIZHIQUEDINGLI,FANGZHIBUQISUHOUDESUIYIZAISU

  YOUXIAOGUIZHIXUANZEXINGBUQISUDELANYONG,HUANYAOJIEJUEHAOBUQISUHOUDESUIYIZHONGXINQISUWENTI。XINGSHISUSONGFADUIYUJIANCHAJIGUANBUQISUHOUYOUZHONGXINQISUDE,MEIYOUGUIDINGMINGQUEDEXIANZHITIAOJIAN,YIZHISHIJIANZHONGYIXIEDIFANGJIANCHAJIGUANZAIBUQISUHOUDEZHONGXINQISUFANGMIANJIAOWEISUIYI,QIZHONGBUPAICHUDAIYOUBAOFUXINGSECAIDEZHONGXINQISU。

  YOUXUEZHERENWEI,WEIFANGZHIJIANCHAJIGUANBUQISUHOUDESUIYIZAISUQINHAIBEIZHUISURENDECHENGXUANDINGQUAN,YINGDANGFUYUBUQISUJUEDINGYIYISHIBUZAILIDESHIZHIQUEDINGLI。BIZHERENWEI,ZHESHIYIZHONGWEIBEISUSONGFALIQIEBUNENGYOUXIAOJIEJUEXIANSHIWENTIDEJIBINGLUANTOUYISHIDEYINGDUIFANGAN,18QIZAIMANZUFADEANDINGXINGXUYAODETONGSHI,YEFENGDULEFADEGONGZHENGXINGZHUIQIU。ZHENGRURIBENXUEZHESUOZHICHUDE,BUQISUCHUFENSHIXINGZHENGCHUFEN,BUJUYOUPANJUEJIPANLIDEXIAOLI,QIEBINGBUYINCIERXIAOMIEGONGSUQUAN。SUOYI,JIBIANYIJINGZUOCHUBUQISUCHUFENDEANJIAN,DANGYIJUBEIQIANQUEDESUSONGTIAOJIAN,HUOYINFAXIANXINZHENGJUERXIANYIYICHONGFEN,HUOYINFASHENGXINQINGKUANGERCHUYUSHIYIQISUDEZHUANGTAISHI,ZHIYAOGONGSUSHIXIAOMEIYOUWANCHENG,JIUKEYITIQIGONGSU。[29]P198WOGUOTAIWANXUEZHEYEZHICHU,YOUYUJIANCHAGUANZHIBUQISUCHUFEN,JIUQIXINGZHIERYAN,JINXISUQUANZHIWEIXINGSHIERYI,JIYINANJIANWEIFAXIANQIJUBEIKENENGTIAOJIANHUOBIYAOTIAOJIANZHIGU,JIFEISUQUANZHIFANGQI,GENGFEISUQUANZHIXIAOMIEYUANYIN,SHIYIANJIANSUIJINGJIANCHAGUANCHUFENBUQISU,YINGJINXIJIANCHAJIGUANNEIBUSUOWEIZHIJUEDING,RENGSHUZHENCHAJIEDUAN,BUYIYOUHEJUSHULI,GENGBUYIYOUHEQUEDINGLI。[30]P124

秒速赛车6码计划   SHENYANZHI,JIWANGYUTONGGUOFUYUBUQISUJUEDINGYISHIZHIQUEDINGLILAIFANGFANBUQISUHOUDESUIYIZAISU,BUJINHUIWEIBEIFAYUANZUIZHONGJUEDINGYUANZEHEKONGSHENFENLIYUANZE,LILUNSHANGQUEFAZUGOUDEHELIXING,ERQIEGENGZHUYAODESHI,QIZAISHIJIANZHONGDEFUMIANXIAOYINGJIAODA,RONGYIFANGZONGFANZUI,JINERYINFAMINZHONGDEBUMANHESIFAGONGXINLIDEXIAJIANG,BIJINGSHISHIQIUSHI、YOUCUOBIJIURENGSHIWOGUOGUOMINDEZHUDAOXINGSIFALINIAN。

秒速赛车6码计划   ZAIBIZHEKANLAI,JIEJUEBUQISUHOUYOUSUIYIZAISUDEWENTI,SHOUXIANYINGDANGSHIXIANJIYAQIXIANYUBANANQIXIANDEFENLIYIJIJIYACUOSHIDESIFAKONGZHI,FOUZE,YOUYUMUQIANDEFALVGUIDING,ZAITAOLUNZIYIZHONGFUZHUISUDEKONGZHISHI,WANGWANGHUIMISHIFANGXIANG,YIZHICHUXIANLEISISHANGSHUYOUBEIFALIDEGUANDIAN。

  DANGRAN,ZAIQIANGZHICUOSHIDESIFASHENCHAYUANZEQUELIZHIQIAN,SUIBUYIFUYUJIANCHAJIGUANDEBUQISUJUEDINGYIYISHIBUZAILIDESHIZHIQUEDINGLI,DANRENGYINGFUYUQIYIDINGDESHIZHIQUEDINGLI,GUIDINGBUQISUJUEDINGZUOCHUYIHOU,JIANCHAJIGUANZHIYOUZAIFAXIANXINSHISHIHUOZHEXINZHENGJUSHI,CAIKEYIZAIXINGQISU。YINWEIQUBIEYUXIFANGGUOJIA,ZAIWOGUO,XINGSHIQISUTONGCHANGDOUHUIBANSUIZHUJIYAYIJIYINJIYADAILAIDEZIYOUXIANZHI、JINGSHENJIANAO、JINGJISUNSHI、QINQINGSHULIDENGZHUDUOSHIZHIXINGDEBULIHOUGUOHELIYISANGSHI,SUOYIFUYUBUQISUJUEDINGYIDINGDESHIZHIQUEDINGLI,FANGFANJIANCHAJIGUANZIYIZHONGXINQISU、BUDUANSAORAOHEDAYABEIGAORENDEXIANXIANG,KEYIGENGHAODIJIANGUSHIZHIZHENGYIDESHIXIANHEBEIGAORENDECHENGXUANDINGXINGLIYIDENGHEFAQUANYIDEBAOHU。

  參考文獻
  [1] 劉木木.廣西陽朔原國土局長受賄案筆錄曝光:收錢的不止他[N].成都商報,2014-07-14.
  [2] 張旭,李峰.論刑事訴訟中的“選擇性起訴”[J].法學評論,2006,4;段明學.論選擇起訴[J].中國刑事法雜志,2007,6;王兆鵬.報復性起訴[J].月旦法學雜志,2013,12.
  [3] 周長軍.檢察起訴裁量權的國際發展趨勢與中國改革[J].東方法學,2009,3.
  [4] 段明學.論選擇起訴[J].中國刑事法雜志,2007,6.
  [5] 謝小劍.公訴權制約制度研究[M].北京:法律出版社,2009.
  [6] 方工.選擇性辦案對反腐斗爭極為不利[N].檢察日報,2014-03-25.
  [7] 褚朝新,羅婷.行賄的官員個個都在?[N].南方周末,2013-09-26.
  [8] 楊濤.行賄者法不責眾潛規則當休[N].法制日報,2014-04-28.
  [9] 周清樹.茂名窩案卷宗里的官場細節[N].新京報,2014-04-26.
  [10] 崔烜,趙淑菊.山東“雙面記者”遭遇漏罪追訴[N].時代周報,2011-06-16.
  [11] 楊濤.鄭少東案啟示:警惕“另案處理”[EB/OL].鳳凰網,2010-01-28.
  [12] 陳新民.德國公法學基礎理論(下冊)[M].濟南:山東人民出版社,2001.
  [13] [英]T.R.S.艾倫.法律、自由與正義——英國憲政的法律基礎[M].成協中,江菁,譯.北京:法律出版社,2006.
  [14] [日]蘆部信喜.憲法(第六版)[M].林來梵等,譯.北京:清華大學出版社,2018.
  [15] 周少華.作為目的的一般預防[J].法學研究,2008,2.
  [16] 周光權.論刑法的公眾認同[J].中國法學,2003,2.
  [17] 林鈺雄.檢察官論[M].臺北:學林文化事業有限公司,1999.
  [18] 高銘暄,馬克昌.刑法學[M].北京:北京大學出版社、高等教育出版社,2011.
  [19] 魏曉娜.完善認罪認罰從寬制度——中國語境下的關鍵詞展開[J].法學研究,2016,4.
  [20] 王愛立.中華人民共和國刑事訴訟法釋義[M].北京;法律出版社,2018.
  [21] [美] 斯蒂芬諾斯·畢貝斯.庭審之外的辯訴交易[M].楊先德,廖鈺,譯.北京:中國法制出版社,2018.
  [22] [美]安吉娜·J.戴維斯.專橫的正義:美國檢察官的權力[M].李昌林,陳川陵,譯.北京:中國法制出版社,2012.
  [23] Thomas Weigend,Continental Cures for American Ailments:European Criminal Procedure as a Model for Law Reform,2 CRIME & JUST.381,389 (1980).
  [24] Joachim Herrmann,The Rule of Compulsory Prosecution and the Scope of Prosecutorial Discretion in Germany,41 U.CHI.L.REV.468,469 (1974).
  [25] 德國刑事訴訟法典[M].宗玉琨,譯注.北京:知識產權出版社,2013.
  [26] 陳宏毅.追訴犯罪與法本質之研究[M].臺北:鼎茂圖書出版股份有限公司,2003.
  [27] [美]喬治·費希爾.辯訴交易的勝利——美國辯訴交易史[M].郭志媛,譯.北京:中國政法大學出版社,2012.
  [28] 彭新林.可確立腐敗犯罪污點證人作證豁免制度[N].檢察日報,2015-05-06.
  [29] [日]土本武司.日本刑事訴訟法要義[M].董璠輿,宋英輝,譯.臺北:五南圖書出版公司,1997.
  [30] 林俊益.刑事訴訟法概論(下)[M].臺北:學林文化事業出版公司,2003.